Posted on 04/18/2018 11:15:27 AM PDT by ethom
Would America Vote for Oprah for President?
The speculation centered on Winfreys possible presidential bid while encouraging on its own lacks a full assessment of all that Winfrey brings to the table. The experiences of black women, even those that are high-profile, are often constrained by how people view them.
By The Conversation
April 17, 2018
Would America vote for Oprah for president
America has had a black president.
Is the country ready for a black president who is also a woman?
Speculation about the candidacy of Oprah Winfrey makes clear that some voters think so. Granted, Winfrey says she wont run, but friends, commentators and many in the Twitterverse are pushing for her to reconsider.
As a scholar of race and politics, Im curious about whether Oprah will change her mind about running and even more curious about whether she could win.
Occupying a unique space
A paper I recently published with Harwood McClerking and Ray Block tried to shed light on this question by examining Oprahs first major foray into politics her endorsement of Democratic candidate Barack Obama during the 2008 presidential election. Specifically, we wanted to know how the endorsement altered the publics perception of her, as a way of understanding if people like the idea of a political Oprah.
First, it helps to understand just how popular Oprah was leading up to the 2008 election. From 2002 to 2006, Winfreys daytime talk show pulled in an estimated 7 million viewers every day. Winfrey also had racial crossover appeal, maintaining an audience that was predominately female, white and over the age of 55.
During this phase of her career, Oprah avoided politics, a strategy that may have helped her transcend her race, to borrow a phrase from political scientists Donald Kinder and Corrine McConnaughy.
For example, in an interview with the Jacksonville Daily News in 1986, Oprah described her high school experience: Everyone went through the black-power phase (but) I knew I was not a dashiki kind of girl.
Talking to People Weekly a year later, Oprah said that during college at Tennessee State, a historically black college, she refused to conform to the militant thinking of the time.
People feel you have to lead a civil rights movement every day of your life, that you have to be a spokeswoman and represent the race, Oprah said. Blackness is something I just am.
Writing in 1994, media scholar Janice Peck asserted that Winfrey served as a comforting, nonthreatening bridge between black and white culture. She goes on to say that Winfrey minimized her race through public rejection of black political activism and the Civil Rights Movement.
Winfreys Obama endorsement
Michelle and Barack Obama campaign with Oprah Winfrey in 2008. AP Photo/Mary Ann Chastain
This notion of Winfreys racial transcendence was tested in May 2007 with her explicit endorsement of Obama, which made her racial identity and political views salient to the American people. This connection was not lost on viewers, some of whom said she was trying to sway her mass following.
Politics scholar Costas Panagopoulos predicted that the endorsement would cause Winfreys popularity to suffer. It didnt help that Winfreys endorsement of Obama alienated her from white women the largest segment of her audience who believed that, as a woman, she should have backed Hillary Clinton.
Winfrey and black womens consciousness
Oprah isnt the first black woman to struggle with two minority identities.
Gender studies scholars find that historically, black women reside in a unique space where they are marginalized by black communities due to their gender and sidelined by the feminist movement due to their race.
Claudine Gay and Katherine Tate assert in their research that the experience of being doubly bounded has resulted in the formation of a black female consciousness. Gender and legal scholar Kimberle Crenshaw argues that the experiences faced by black women cannot be understood through traditional understanding of race and gender discrimination. Crenshaw believes that the intersection of racism and sexism interact in a way resulting in shared experience with discrimination that is more severe for black women. To describe this situation, Crenshaw coined the term intersectionality.
The fragility of racial transcendence
To understand Winfreys transcendence and its fragility, we used Harris Polls measure of how Winfrey ranked relative to other television personalities regularly during a large span of her talk show, from 1993 to 2011. In the years leading up to her Obama endorsement 2002 to 2006 she was the nations favorite television personality. But immediately following her endorsement, her favorability dropped to No. 4. Over the next five years until her show ended in 2011, Oprahs average ranking was No. 3.
Before her endorsement of Obama, individuals were favorable toward Winfrey at relatively equal levels between 73 and 82 percent regardless of their race and gender. After the endorsement, a gap opened up. Black women rated her 86.2 percent favorable. Black men still maintain the second highest favorability, but we see a drop from 81 percent to 72 percent. Similarly, the percentage of white women who hold favorable ratings of Winfrey drops from 73.4 percent pre-endorsement to 67.8 percent after.
By examining post-endorsement polling data, we argue that the impact of Oprahs endorsement is an important factor that seems to follow the same breakdown. Her endorsement had the strongest tangible effect on black women, followed by black men, white women and white men.
These numbers are important when considering Oprahs electability because blacks make up only 11.9 percent of the electorate. Having black support alone is not enough to win the presidency. Indeed, Obama built his success on support beyond the black community by having high levels of turnout from voters under the age of 30, low- to moderate-income workers those earning less than $50,000 and Latinos.
Oprah 2020?
Despite the seeming impact on her popularity, Winfrey has become more political over time.
For instance, in a recent series of articles in Oprah Magazine and on Oprah.com, Winfrey discusses race and racial awareness in a very different way than those interviews from the 80s.
In one article, she writes, The audacity it takes to judge another because they dont look or sound or act like you goes against the current of humanity. In another: We cant afford to say race is just a black thing, or a Hispanic thing, or an Asian thing or a #StayWoke thing. Its a human thing.
The speculation centered on Winfreys possible presidential bid while encouraging on its own lacks a full assessment of all that Winfrey brings to the table. The experiences of black women, even those that are high-profile, are often constrained by how people view them.
The ConversationOprahs claim that times up inspired many, but our research suggests that the more political Oprah becomes, the more aware voters will be of her race and gender. And that awareness will give her not one, but two, challenges to overcome.
NO I would not
Here’s an idea: nominate her dumb a$$ and find out.
Not just NO! But heck NO!!
Poll after a few months of BLAH BLAH campaigning
VJ has picked her candidate.
Its either going to be Holder or Oprah.
VJ, who picked Obama has already kicked Hillary and Biden to the curb.
Cory Booker is going to be VP in any case.
These “white women” are a disgrace to “white women” everywhere. Don’t they understand that oprah (among other things) is a racist who is full of hate?
President of what?
Celebrities are always popular candidates when the question is in the abstract. Sort of how when the home football team is struggling the back up quarterback is the most popular guy on the team. But then when you have to get in the ring things change fast.
Talk Show President , all scripted , all Fake
She said she won’t run, so what difference does it make?
How long would it be before President Big Bucks started demanding “reparations” for her people?
Hi, I’m Oprah.
I’m the spokesperson for Weight Watchers but can’t
control my weight.
I tell you how to run your marriage but I can’t commit to marriage.
I tell you how to raise your kids but I dont have any.
I am very spiritual, but dont go to any church or identify as Christian.
Even though I knew about Weinstein and the casting couch,
I was silent, but I support the Me Too movement.
I am racist to the core, but blacks cant really be racist, so that doesnt count.
Im black and female, so I check all the boxes.
I praised Denmark for their Socialism, though I am a billionaire due to Capitalism, the economic system that allowed a dirt-poor child from Mississippi to rise to world-renowned fame and wealth.
The first time I openlyendorsed a presidential candidate it was a black one, Obama.
Before a black candidate, I was not political.
Vote for me, and I will give you transformational change.
Omce Oprah gets in & gets bloodied by the GOP her poll #'s will be down like 20% or more LOL
Oprah doesn’t want her Life(and Business Dealings) open to the World
She would get a free pass on everything! she’s already enrolled in two government-certified victim groups, and would be able to totally screw up the country and get praised for it.
Not me.
Not even at gunpoint.
Democrats PLEEEZE nominate her PLEEEEEZE do it!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.