[Leaning Right]

Okay, let's assume that the cop really has a knee injury. So no more walking the beat for her. Why then wasn't she assigned to some other duty, like answering 911 calls?

A disability finding should not lead to retirement. It should lead to be assigned some other duty. But I guess that might offend some group somewhere, so never mind.

[ltc8k6]

That’s the key question. Even if it were true that she could not run any more, there are plenty of jobs in the NYPD that she could still do.