Posted on 10/31/2016 9:37:51 AM PDT by 2ndDivisionVet
The bookies' odds now give Trump a better chance than the polls and an analysis of the electoral college would suggest he has despite his improving numbers
Donald Trump’s odds of winning the US Presidential election have halved - but he still remains a long shot to walk into the Oval Office.
The revelation that the FBI has reopened its investigation into his Democratic opponent Hilary Clinton’s use of a private e-mail server while Secretary of State is the latest scandal to impact upon the race.
Share
While Trump had been trading at around 5-1 when I analysed the betting markets last Wednesday, his price fell to as low as 2-1 over the weekend. At the time of writing several bookies went going 9-4 on a Trump victory although it wasn’t hard to find the reality TV star and businessman at 11-4.
That latter price implies that he has a 26.7 per cent chance of winning, compared to 16.7 per cent implied by his pervious odds of 5-1. It's a considerable move in his favour.
By contrast FiveThrityEight, which uses polling and other data to produce its forecasts, rates his chance at 21 per cent using a polls only model and 23 per cent using polls plus historical and economic data. So while there appears to be little value in backing Trump at 11-4, Clinton at 1-3 looks under priced.
Part of the betting move has been fuelled by a string of polls that suggest the race is tightening. The BBC’s latest polls of polls, which uses the median average of the five most recent national US polls, has Clinton at 49 per cent and Trump at 46 per cent. The Washington Post-ABC tracking poll has Clinton at 46 per cent and Trump at 45 per cent, including third party candidates.
FiveThirtyEight's Nat Silver, however, notes that Trump had been enjoying a surge in support before Friday’s news about Clinton’s e-mail server, which might have had less of an impact than some commentators suggested, perhaps because it is already on Clinton’s “rap sheet”. It is therefore open to debate whether Friday’s news, by itself, will have changed many people’s views about her.
If the prospect of Trump in the White House makes you shudder, the fact that betting patterns on the US election so closely mirror the betting patterns seen ahead of the UK’s EU referendum, with smaller punters who backed Brexit backing Trump while big money punters who backed remain backing Clinton, is worrying enough. The latest Trump surge will have exacerbated those worries.
Alex Donohue at Ladbrokes said of the latest betting: “There has actually been a small move back to Hillary this morning (1/3 from 4/11) which is due to some of the larger staking players backing her whenever her price hits a certain point - clearly they are many who believe they can extract some value from the way the prices have been manipulated by the masses of smaller-staking Trump voters.
“Certainly some of the high-rolling Hillary backers believe anything related to emails is pretty much priced in anyway, so she looks a very attractive bet at 1/3 compared to far shorter odds offered last week.”
By contrast, Graham Sharpe at William Hill, said: “We’ve seen virtually nothing of any significance for Hillary. Trump has come down and is making the running. We’re interested to see where the next move goes.”
Part of the reason Clinton is starting to look like value at 1-3 is that it is the US electoral college that elects the President and not the popular vote. The college favours Clinton.
Indications from early voting in both North Carolina and Nevada suggest that these two battleground states have been trending in her direction. The Trump surge would need to continue, and strongly, if he were to overcome her cushion in those states.
Alternatively he needs to take some of the other in play states that have looked like they are in Clinton’s column, such as Wisconsin and Michigan, assuming (as looks likely and as I have tipped) he takes Ohio and also Iowa (and Arizona).
Wisconsin, however, also has early voting (not all states do). New Hampshire is also in play as is the second district of Maine (it assigns its college votes based on the results in each of three districts).
Sporting Index’s spread on Clinton’s performance in the college has fallen to 303-315, down from 325-335. That still represents a comfortable win for Clinton. Using FiveThirtyEight’s polls plus forecasts, which are more favourable to Trump, and assuming they are correct for each state, Clinton should win 319 votes. Which makes the spread worth a modest buy at 315. I'm assuming with that recommendation that Clinton takes the mid western states she is expected to (Michigan, Minnesota, Wisconsin, Illinois), Florida, North Carolina, Maine and New Hampshire, while losing Iowa, Ohio, and Arizona.
Why would I remain a Clinton backer? The “Brexit” effect can’t be ignored, Trump rage filled supporters have much in common with Brexit backers, but none of the motley crew of Brexiteers that led the two Leave campaigns had the same level of scandal attached to them as does Trump and I’d be willing to bet that the next rumpus to emerge out of a campaign with more twists than a John Grisham legal thriller, impacts on him.
THE RATS WON'T LET GO OF THE EXECUTIVE POSITION WITHOUT A H*LL OF A FIGHT. THE DUMBED DOWN AMERICANS, THE GIBS ME DATS WHO PUT OBAMA IN THE WHITE HOUSE ARE STILL OUT THERE.
HILLARY WAS SO CLOSE- AND SHE KNOWS THIS IS HER LAST CHANCE. SHE WILL COME UP WITH SOMETHING AT THE LAST MINUTE
THE RATS ARE SCARED TO DEATH DONALD WILL UNDO THE DAMAGE THEY AND OBAMA HAVE DONE TO OUR COUNTRY. THERE WILL BE MASSIVE VOTER FRAUD.
WE ARE AT OUR CROSSROADS IN HISTORY. WE MUST WIN THIS! THIS IS THE MOST IMPORTANT ELECTION OF OF OUR LIFETIMES
GET OUT AND VOTE! WE MUST MAKE THIS THE BIGGEST REPUBLICAN VOTER TURNOUT IN HISTORY!
(See Tag)
Bookies? If there is justice, the bookies too, will lose!
Go, Trump, GO!
The problem is that, as long as Clinton takes the Northeast and the West Coast, she has over 200 EVs before the rest of the country weighs in. In a nameless contest, I’d predict a Democrat win with that advantage and be right most of the times.
Republicans have to “run the table” of the South, Midwest and Mountain states (minus hopeless and crooked Illinois) to win the election.
In other words, winning the election is likely playing the Patriots if they start every possession on the 50 yard line.
So, don’t rejoice yet. we still have a lot to go.
I don’t think the full impact of this has hit yet.
Anybody who picked Trump first thing is going to make a mint.
Wouldn’t it be amusing to know where Soros had his money?
DON't become overconfident. NEVER UNDERESTIMATE THE CLINTON CRIME FAMILY. THE RATS WON'T LET GO OF THE EXECUTIVE POSITION WITHOUT A H*LL OF A FIGHT. THE DUMBED DOWN AMERICANS, THE GIBS ME DATS WHO PUT OBAMA IN THE WHITE HOUSE ARE STILL OUT THERE.
HILLARY WAS SO CLOSE- AND SHE KNOWS THIS IS HER LAST CHANCE. SHE WILL COME UP WITH SOMETHING AT THE LAST MINUTE THE RATS ARE SCARED TO DEATH DONALD WILL UNDO THE DAMAGE THEY AND OBAMA HAVE DONE TO OUR COUNTRY. THERE WILL BE MASSIVE VOTER FRAUD.
WE ARE AT OUR CROSSROADS IN HISTORY. WE MUST WIN THIS! THIS IS THE MOST IMPORTANT ELECTION OF OF OUR LIFETIMES.
GET OUT AND VOTE! WE MUST MAKE THIS THE BIGGEST REPUBLICAN VOTER TURNOUT IN HISTORY!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.