Your third scenario misses the mark (you are right with the first two). If the GOP gives him the tax he wants it will do nothing to improve the economy in any way. In fact things will slide further. The GOP could then run on the fact that they comprimised big time and look what happened. It might not work but it is the only chance for 2014.
Newt says there is no fiscal cliff.
http://www.gingrichproductions.com/2012/11/there-is-no-fiscal-cliff/
“Your third scenario misses the mark (you are right with the first two). If the GOP gives him the tax he wants it will do nothing to improve the economy in any way. In fact things will slide further.”
No, not off the mark.
The reality is that in America today, it doesn’t really matter to a large part of the voting population whether the economy is improving or not.
If it did, how did Obama persuade a majority of Americans to vote for him, in one of the worst economic environments (of his own making) in American history?
If it did, Obama would have lost. He did not lose. He won.
The “new reality” of American politics (in the new “divided America”) is that the successful promulgation of a theme is more important than reality. Because in the new America, we have a growing share of the population that has no idea of what economic “reality” even -is-. And wouldn’t be able to comprehend it in any case.
Perception has become “the new reality”.
Apply this to my scenario #3, and you’ll see how that will work for the ‘rats in 2014. It may even work BETTER for them than scenarios #1 and #2....
Aside: Who cares about unemployment when you’re gettin’ your free ObamaPhone?