Skip to comments.
Fair Trade Revealed As Just a Feel-Good Hoax
Kids Prefer Cheese ^
Posted on 05/16/2011 4:50:55 AM PDT by SeekAndFind
I have for some time been a basher and hater of "Fair Trade," in coffee and other commodities. In fact, as far as I'm concerned, Russ Roberts and I podcastrated the whole issue nearly four years ago. Sarah Marchmont wrote a very fair-minded article about it.
Here is the basic economics--a rent is being created: a price above market price is being charged. In countries where property rights, contracts, and rule of law is tenuous, feel-gooders and scam artists have put together an unholy coalition. The feel-gooders create something called "Fair Trade" certification, which means that the farmers get paid well above market price for the coffee they produce.
Not surprisingly, many farmers want to get in on this action. But less than all can be certified "fair trade" recipients, since a price that much above the market price would create a surplus. The fair trade feel-gooders would never be able to sell the glut of coffee if EVERYONE gets fair trade certification.
So, the feel-gooders stick their fingers in their ears and shout "LA-LA-LA-LA-LA" and pretend that their partners the scam artists are doing the right thing when they hand out the "fair trade" certifications.
But remember that these are countries with little rule of law, and shoddy police enforcement. So what the scam artists in effect do is sell off the rent (the high price of fair trade certification) to the highest bidder.
The result is that, after a fairly short period, three years at most, the "fair trade" farmers are getting no more, and maybe less, than everyone else, and no more than they got before the "fair trade" scam was started. The scam artists, it's true, are skimming the profits, but the competition to become a scam artist then becomes the valuable commodity, and rent-seeking to get to be the guy who certifies "fair trade" then also dissipates THAT rent. Some government official in the country, the one who licenses the guy who licenses the guy who certifies "fair trade" farmers ends up sucking down the rent.
Consumers pay more, and feel good about themselves. The feel-gooders who started the program move on to abuse some other group of farmers with false promises. And the results are a substantial increase in dead-weight loss.
Don't believe me? Article in the National Post, by Lawrence Solomon, founder of Green Beanery in Toronto, a suburb of Buffalo.
And the German study that really reveals how it all works. In fact, as the Hohenheimers note, the certification process is so corrupt many don't even bother, and just mislabel the coffee as "fair trade" from the get-go.
All you need to know to figure out why "fair trade" and similar feel good programs are dumb is have lunch with Bob Tollison once, and have him explain what rent-seeking is. Or you can read this, I suppose, though Bob is a better bet. (Dr. Henderson gives a nice short history.) The point is that once you understand rent-seeking, you can PREDICT that stuff like "fair trade" won't work. It can't work. And it doesn't work.
UPDATE: Dalibor Rohac has a nice piece on same subject. Thanks for the tip, DR!
Labels: Fair Trade
TOPICS: Business/Economy; Politics; Society
KEYWORDS: fairtrade; protectionism; tariffs; trade
The only reason liberals call it “fair” trade is because it’s rigged.
posted on 05/16/2011 5:57:00 AM PDT
I bought Fair Trade coffee a couple times a few years ago but quickly decided it wasn’t worth it to me. Now I’m glad.
posted on 05/16/2011 6:12:36 AM PDT
(Islam is as Islam does.)
My first thought was that if the farmers are not doing well on coffee, they should make a priority of planting stuff that they can eat. Then I remembered that this isn’t the good ol’ USA we’re talking about; they don’t have much of a choice since they are not owners.
posted on 05/16/2011 6:22:20 AM PDT
(Excising a cancer before it kills us waters the Tree of Liberty! TERM LIMITS, NOW AND FOREVER!)
Rush once said,and I’m paraphrasing, ...’anything or organization that cloaks itself with the word ‘fair’ ...isn’t.
posted on 05/16/2011 8:28:13 AM PDT
posted on 11/01/2011 2:27:30 PM PDT
(Today is already the tomorrow which the bad economist yesterday urged us to ignore. - HAZLITT)
Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual
posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its
management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the
exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson