I will say 2 things.
Smith is underrated by some.
And overrated by some.
He’s good. Maybe even very good.
he’s not above very good and not below good in any way.
With a good defense, and including the games where he can put up 40 points, he can take a team to the superbowl.
Worse QBs than him have.
But no, he’s not top tier and I hope this new guy is as good as you say he is.
It’s been a while for Skins fans and I just want to see their name in the late stage playoffs so leftists can go insane :)
I actually am a Cowboy fan, but I respect the rivalry and the Washington Team. I also attended UT, so I am very familiar with Colt McCoy. He was always an overachiever at Texas because he didn’t have the prototypical size and athleticism of an NFL Quarterback. But he was always a leader, and I have no doubt that he will be an addition, not a subtraction...At any rate, I still think that the NFL East is wide open, including Washington, Philadelphia and Dallas. New York might surprise them all.