Posted on 11/30/2014 3:13:07 PM PST by EveningStar
Now that the trailer for the seventh "Star Wars" movie is out, you can imagine the anticipation among the millions of fans of the film franchise. And why not? The six "Star Wars" films have been enormous successes: they have grossed over $2 billion domestically at the box office, spawned scores of books, comic books and merchandise (how many kids have their own light saber?) and made household names of characters like Darth Vader, Han Solo and Luke Skywalker.
They've also been the worst thing ever for the science fiction genre.
(Excerpt) Read more at cnn.com ...
ping
Who the **** cares what some CNN reporter thinks?
Editor's note: Lewis Beale writes about culture and film for the Los Angeles Times, Newsday and other publications.The opinions expressed in this commentary, which is updated from an earlier version, are solely those of the author.
CNN is the worse thing that happened to journalism.
This is the Arabic character "nun" the first letter of the word "Nazarene." I post it as my avatar in solidarity with people of all faiths suffering persecution at the hands of Islam. Many of them are members of the oldest of our Christian Communities, dating from the days of the Apostles. They endure cruel, merciless and unrelenting persecution. They are Orthodox and Catholic, Protestant and Evangelical, Coptic, Pentecostal, and Baptist. To the persecutors they, and we, are all "Nazarenes." |
Star Wars isn’t science fiction. It’s romantic fantasy set in space.
CC
Really hates SF about people overthrowing an oppressive government. SF about politicians who appear to be the good guy, turning out to be evil.
No doubt. It has more in common with Lord of the Rings than 2001.
Star Wars isnt science fiction. Its romantic fantasy set in space.
Absolutely agree.
I wish someone would do “The Mote in God’s Eye.”
Star Wars was a fun film, kind of like Raiders of the Lost Ark. But Hollywood isn’t about great thoughts. Hollywood thrives on mediocrity, and it does so because that is what a film maker can promise the money men.
Genius is great, but it isn’t something one can promise. A film maker can promise sex scenes, but he cannot promise romance between characters the audience cares about. The maker can promise violence, but he cannot promise suspense. In like manner, he can promise action, but not a stirring of the soul. And movies are financed by what can be promised, not by what one can hope for.
TV is actually a better medium, because 26 shows a season means a few can be special. The original Star Trek had some pee-poor episodes, but they had a few meant to provoke thought - like raisins in a muffin. A TV series can afford raisins. A movie only has one shot, and no one wants to take a chance.
Good analogy. Makes sense IAW with follow the money.
Great book that one.
L
. Propaganda is propaganda, and is never art.
Star Wars is light fare. It hasn't ruined anything. It got people of a certain age interested in science fiction, and to the extent that it interested them in other, "deeper" ψφ fare it was not a bad thing. I seriously doubt about half of the "meaningful" ψφ the author of the piece obviously prefers and is overlooking in his silly rant would ever have been made had not Star Wars been a commercial success.
He's complaining because every cowboy movie isn't The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance or The Shootist while forgetting that silly Tom Mix serials and really stupid "singing cowboys" made those films possible.
D+.
I think he was using that more to point out that the Sci-Fi genre encompasses more than Star Wars / Star Trek pop-culture ideas.
When he returns to the thesis, he says Hollywood studios, not known for thinking outside the box, opt for the "Star Wars" template -- lots of whiz bang, plenty of quirky alien characters, CGI to the max, plenty of explosions and little thought of any kind.
and I'm inclined to agree; the only good sci-fi movie I've seen in [fairly] recent years is Serenity. (Star Trek Into Darkness was a poorly done ST II: Wrath of Kahn remake; Green Lantern could have been really good, if they didn't try shoehorning two and a half movies into a single one.)
Really hates SF about people overthrowing an oppressive government. SF about politicians who appear to be the good guy, turning out to be evil.
Well, there's some SF like that, but there's a lot that's about exploring an idea.
Minority Report, for example, is about what police/law-enforcement would be like if there was precognition.
Star Wars isn’t Scifi
SciFi:
Time Travel
Travel By Black Holes
Space
War of the Worlds
Forbidden Planet
Fantasy:
Space Fantasy (Star Wars, Battle Star Galactica)
Other World Fantasy (Lord of the Rings, Farscape, ...)
Dragons
Magic, Sorcery
Not SciFi
Horror
Werewolves
Vampires
Frankenstein
Zombies
Ghosts
Goblins
Spirits
Devils and Angels
Monsters
Aliens
Correct. Buck Rogers stuff updated.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.