I do agree that Genesis was better when Banks and Rutherford were doing the writing and Phil drummed and sang....A Trick of the Tail is a fantastic album.
Honestly-I have tried to like Genesis. Just can’t. Not to my taste.
Do Blues (All kinds), progressive (Dream Theater, Buckethead), Guitar (Steve Morse, Gary Moore), Hard (Sabbath, Heep, Purple).
Genesis and Collins just make me retch. The two fastest ways to get me to change a radio station is to play Collins/Genesis or Def Leppard.
Once again-personal tastes
Squonk
Concur