We don’t have “Fareway” around here, so I can’t comment.
The local store brands I’ve tried aren’t that great. We do occasionally splurge and get some of that “whole peanut” natural stuff that’s nothing but mashed peanuts.
It’s pretty good but has a tendency to separate.
I wonder, can you jusy buy some peanuts and make your own “Peanut Butter”? If so, how?