Posted on 08/25/2012 7:49:29 AM PDT by SeekAndFind
Global Finance magazine is out with its annual report cards for the world's most influential central bankers. The grades, which range from A to F, are based on banker's success in controlling inflation, fostering economic growth, and managing interest rates.
Other factors include the banker's ability to stand up to political pressure and influence government in a positive way.
In what's been an incredibly difficult economic environment, here are the central bankers who have had a steady hand on the wheel.
(Excerpt) Read more at businessinsider.com ...
kind of an odd ratings system going on unemployment and inflation
a number of those countries have low unemployment but are very agrarian or have really poor paying jobs
not a decent comparison
besides we are still living in the aftermath of Greenspan and three decades of legislative and executive prodding to sell homes to those who can’t afford them
NIGERIA!?!? I’m sorry but that is funny right there... 23% unemployment and 12% inflation. Great job. The others on the list I tend to agree with but I think that Nigeria is a tad ridiculous.
/-sarc
Those Central Bankers scoring an "A" in the report published in the October issue of Global Finance include:
Australia | Glenn Stevens | A |
Canada | Mark Carney | A |
Israel | Stanley Fischer | A |
Malaysia | Zeti Akhtar Aziz | A |
Philippines | Amando Tetangco Jr. | A |
Taiwan | Fai-Nan Perng | A |
CENTRAL BANKER REPORT CARDS 2012
Country | Central Bank Governors |
Grade 2012 |
Grade 2011 |
Argentina | Mercedes Marcó del Pont |
D |
D |
Brazil | Alexandre Tombini | B | B+ |
Canada | Mark Carney | A | B+ |
Chile | Rodrigo Vergara | B+ | * |
Columbia | José Dario Uribe Escobar | B | N/A** |
Ecuador | Pedro Delgado | D | N/A** |
Mexico | Agustin Carstens | B+ | B |
Peru | José De Gregorio | B | N/A** |
United States | Ben Bernanke | B | C |
Country | Central Bank Governors |
Grade 2012 |
Grade 2011 |
Belarus | Nadezhda Ermakova | C | N/A** |
Czech Republic | Miroslav Singer | B | B |
European Union | Mario Draghi | B- | * |
Hungary | András Simor | C | C |
Norway | Øystein Olsen | B | Too early to say |
Poland | Marek Belka | B- | B |
Russia | Sergei Ignatiev | B+ | B |
Sweden | Stefan Ingves | B | B+ |
Switzerland | Thomas Jordan | Too early to say | * |
Turkey | Erdem Başçi | B | Too early to say |
Ukraine | Serhiy Abruzov | B | N/A** |
United Kingdom | Mervyn King | B- | B |
Country | Central Bank Governors |
Grade 2012 |
Grade 2011 |
Australia | Glenn Stevens | A | A |
Bangladesh | Atiur Rahman | C | N/A** |
China | Zhou Xiaochuan | B- | B |
India | Duvvuri Subbarao | C | B- |
Indonesia | Darmin Nasution | B | B |
Japan | Masaaki Shirakawa | C- | C |
Kazakhstan | Grigori Marchenko | B+ | N/A** |
Malaysia | Zeti Akhtar Aziz | A | A |
New Zealand | Alan Bollard | B | B |
Philippines | Amando Tetangco Jr. | A | A |
Singapore | Ravi Menon | B- | B |
South Korea | Kim Choongsoo | C | C |
Sri Lanka | Ajith Nivard Cabraal | B | N/A** |
Taiwan | Fai-Nan Perng | A | A |
Thailand | Prasarn Trairatvorakul | B+ | B+ |
Vietnam | Nguyen Van Binh | C | N/A** |
Country | Central Bank Governors |
Grade 2012 |
Grade 2011 |
Algeria | Mohammed Laksaci | C | N/A** |
Angola | José de Lima Massano | B | B |
Bahrain | Rasheed Mohammed Al-Maraj | B | B- |
Ethiopia | Teklewold Atnafu | C | N/A** |
Israel | Stanley Fischer | A | A |
Kenya | Njuguna Ndungu | B | N/A** |
Kuwait | Mohammad Yusef Al-Hashel | Too early to say | * |
Lebanon | Riad Salameh | C | A |
Morocco | Abdellatif Jouahri | B- | N/A** |
Nigeria | Sanusi Lamido Sanusi | B+ | B+ |
Qatar | Saud Al-Thani | B | * |
Saudi Arabia | Fahad Al-Mubarak | B+ | * |
South Africa | Gill Marcus | C | C |
United Arab Emirates | Sultan Nasser Al-Suweidi | B | N/A* |
*CB governor was rated in 2011, however, a different governor held the office.
**New country addition to Central Bank Report Cards in 2012, therefore no grade was given in 2011.
A central bank’s “job” is price stability and to attempt to keep unemployment near the natural rate of unemployment (~4% in the US). I’d say that those two factors are the best factors in judging whether a CB is doing it’s job.
Quality of jobs matters but that’s not a CB job to worry about.
There is absolutely no such thing as a good Central Banker. They all have strings pulled by the same puppet master.
Mexico are you serious?
We really have to consider what the state of Nigeria’s economy was BEFORE this Central Banker took over.
I mean, if a Dentist took on the task of fixing the teeth of a man whose dentures were completely rotten when he first came, you can’t blame it on the dentist, if after he slowly did the procedure on the patient, his teeth still does not look like those of a model...
You gotta give him time.
It’s like the US debt situation. Even if Paul Ryan’s plan were to pass, you don’t expect the US to quickly be out of the red do you?
It is the TREND, the DIRECTION the country is going that matters in the short run.
1. |
KfW (Germany) |
26. |
Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (Canada) |
2. |
Bank Nederlandse Gemeenten (BNG) (Netherlands) |
27. |
Svenska Handelsbanken (Sweden) |
3. |
Zürcher Kantonalbank (Switzerland) |
28. |
China Development Bank (China) |
4. |
Landwirtschaftliche Rentenbank (Germany) |
29. |
Bank of New York Mellon Corp (United States) |
5. |
Landeskreditbank Baden-Württemberg - Förderbank (L-Bank) (Germany) |
30. |
Agricultural Development Bank of China (China) |
6. |
Caisse des Depots et Consignations (CDC) (France) |
31. |
National Bank of Abu Dhabi (United Arab Emirates) |
7. |
Nederlandse Waterschapsbank (Netherlands) |
32. |
CoBank ACB (United States) |
8. |
NRW.BANK (Germany) |
33. |
Pohjola Bank (Finland) |
9. |
Banque et Caisse dEpargne de lEtat (Luxembourg) |
34. |
National Bank of Kuwait (Kuwait) |
10. |
Rabobank Group (Netherlands) |
35. |
DZ Bank (Germany) |
11. |
TD Bank Group (Canada) |
36. |
Banque Fédérative du Crédit Mutuel (BFCM) (France) |
12. |
Bank of Nova Scotia (Canada) |
37. |
U.S. Bancorp (United States) |
13. |
DBS Bank (Singapore) |
38. |
National Bank of Canada (Canada) |
14. |
Oversea-Chinese Banking Corp (Singapore) |
39. |
Northern Trust Corp (United States) |
15. |
United Overseas Bank (Singapore) |
40. |
Qatar National Bank (Qatar) |
16. |
Caisse centrale Desjardins (Canada) |
41. |
Samba Financial Group (Saudi Arabia) |
17. |
Royal Bank of Canada (Canada) |
42. |
BancoEstado (Chile) |
18. |
National Australia Bank (Australia) |
43. |
La Banque Postale (France) |
19. |
Commonwealth Bank of Australia (Australia) |
44. |
Bank of Taiwan (Taiwan) |
20. |
Westpac Banking Corporation (Australia) |
45. |
Shizuoka Bank (Japan) |
21. |
Australia and New Zealand Banking Group (Australia) |
46. |
Banco de Chile (Chile) |
22. |
Kiwibank (New Zealand) |
47. |
BNP Paribas (France) |
23. |
HSBC Holdings (United Kingdom) |
48. |
Wells Fargo (United States) |
24. |
Nordea (Sweden) |
49. |
Standard Chartered (United Kingdom) |
25. |
Bank of Montreal (Canada) |
50. |
SEB (Sweden) |
RE: Mexico are you serious?
See my post number 9 as it applies to Nigeria. Same principle applies to Mexico.
Carney's biggest problems are going to be keeping interest rates and the Canadian dollar at reasonable levels. Harper's biggest problem is going to be keeping Carney at his post.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.