American Idol 2012--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^ | January 18, 2012

[silent_jonny]

Wow. That reminds me, Casey has been on the show at least twice this season--once in the audience and again tonight on stage with Seacrest. But he hasn't been invited to sing on the show like other Idol alum.

I believe that picture explains why.

[Netizen]

LOL good one!

http://www.myspace.com/video/tam/old-prospector-will-farrell/10922702

[silent_jonny]

Hi, Bug! :)

Just got here but doesn’t look like I’ve missed much yet...

I hope you didn't miss Stefano!

(that was sarcasm ;)

[silent_jonny]

It looks like Cousin IT and it also looks like a turd!

[silent_jonny]

He was such a drama queen

I don't know--Seacrest and the judges about gave Casey a heart-attack that night. And he'd been in the hospital not long before that.

[silent_jonny]

I can’t see how this song is saluting the troops at all unless you consider that they might not have had leave for a long time.

ROFL! That's going in the Quote File :)

[Miss Didi]

Last night they showed how the Idols were making fun of him because he always pretends he has a kidney stone problem to get out of things.

[silent_jonny]

Jackson, who’s worked with Mariah Carey, Whitney Houston and Aretha Franklin

I'm sure Randy reminded the interviewer of this.

[Miss Didi]

He was James Durban’s best bud on the show and best man.

[twin2]

ROFL! That's going in the Quote File :)

I'm just trying to keep my streak going:)

[silent_jonny]

Thanks my FR friends, you are my excuse to lying to govt. agents:)

LOL! Glad to help :)

After two months of me refusing to answer their survey on if I have flush toilets(!?), they came to my house in person

You're kidding. That's insane.

[silent_jonny]

Good evening, Signorina :)

[Miss Didi]

Ciao, amico mio! :)

[Clint N. Suhks]

Mrs S thinks Joshua might be light in the loafers.

The boys must go but methinks the 12 year old chickie voting block will once again prevail.

[stylecouncilor]

LMAO!

[skateman]

Is “it” also known as Nufsed?

[jocon307]

FINALLY Elise goes home.

Nothing personal, she was OK, but others who were better have gone home first.

Holly I thought was good this week. She did very well with the Miley Cyrus song.

I thought nobody did too good with the queen songs.

This is what I thought all night: Freddie Mercury might have been a buck-toothed fagela, but he was a great singer, uniquely good.

Mr. Mercury you are still sorely missed by me and many others.

[al baby]

Looks like one of the people of wall mart or we be toys and chit

[Chunga]

America got it right this week, and so did you.

And I don't think you're annoying or a Fascist. I think this thread is lucky to have someone of your obvious intellect and musicality grace it, in spite of the rudeness with which you are always treated. Hang in there...don't leave us!

And thanks for not reading this!

[Chunga]

You're welcome! I'll stick around because you've been such a good sport.

I really think it will come down to Phillip Phillips. If he can stay well, it's his. The problem is, his illness, whatever it is, is draining him of his charm. While his vocals are never perfect, he usually has a couple of moments that seduce the votes right out of the tweens and their moms. Plus, if Stevie Nicks says your gorgeous, you're gorgeous, and the tweens and their moms go for that, too.

His energy is obviously down. I wonder what the problem is?

I've never thought he deserved a shot, and not only is he the worst singer of the five remaining, he has the worst voice of the five remaining...and this has been true since Deandre was still competing. He was worse than Van Pelt and Magrane. Even Heejun had a better set of pipes. Phillips was better than Jeremy. That's it.

He is a mediocre bar singer with an acoustic guitar. He will be playing all around my city tonight, in various venues at the same time.

And if he wins I will be extremely happen for him.

Thanks for not reading this!