American Idol 2012--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^ | January 18, 2012

[MagUSNRET]

Caption that one :” Tweedle Dum and Tweedle Dummer”

[silent_jonny]

After the break, Joshua and Hollie are already standing with Seacrest.

Iovine: (On Hollie) I wonder if "Save Me" was a subconcious plea to the audience. B+. (Second song, "The Climb", which he liked better) It was as good as she can do.

Iovine: (On Joshua) Really impressed. Gary U.S. Bonds feel (second song) Emotional, restrained. If Joshua is voted off tonight there is something wrong with the show, the competition, the whole ball of wax.

Again, one is in the bottom three, the other in the top.

Joshua is safe.

Hollie joins Elise on the stools. (booing from the audience)

Hollie Cavanagh

[patriotspride]

Naaaaaaaaaaaa cleaned up Casey still looks like the Lion in Wizard of Oz AFTER the trip to the hair salon ;-)

---

Excellent

[retrokitten]

What are they eating?? It looks like poutine in a cup?

[Shelayne]

BOOOOOO! Hollie in the bottom three!

Dial Idol was just a wee bit OFF! Booooo!

[stylecouncilor]

LMAO!

[silent_jonny]

LOL @ the Steven Tyler/Burger King ad.

[RummyChick]

Was the new boy toy dancing in that JLO commercial??

[silent_jonny]

Welcome, Pat :)

[Shelayne]

LOL!

[Netizen]

Casey reminded me of Yukon Cornelius from Rudolph the Red nosed reindeer.

[stylecouncilor]

LOL! He’s perfect for X-Factor!!

[MagUSNRET]

OH goody...Katy Perrys “Tribute” to the troops begins with pseudo dominatrix fast roping to the stage.........EPIC FAIL

[SilvieWaldorfMD]

Katy looks like Betty Rubble....

[MagUSNRET]

LOL that is a HOOT!!!!!!!!!!!

[silent_jonny]

I don’t understand the military theme of this. Now it’s in night-vision.

[retrokitten]

He used to remind me of that. Now he just looked like someone from the Yukon Territory circa 1860.

[peggybac]

She got a lot of s**t for doing this video. Libs didn’t like it.

[MagUSNRET]

THis is 5 minutes of my life I will never get back!

[Netizen]

Yes, liberal politicians, too even a couple of pubbies.

[retrokitten]

Which I guess is exactly the same thing. LMAO

[MagUSNRET]

This military conservative babe does not like it either. It is crap on a stick

[twin2]

I can’t see how this song is saluting the troops at all unless you consider that they might not have had leave for a long time.

[silent_jonny]

Ah—the judges are gone. And no Seacrest chat. This was pre-taped.

[Mark was here]

Purple hair and knee pads.

[RummyChick]

[silent_jonny]

Hi, EG! Great to see you :)

[Netizen]

There is something just wrong with his new look. The hair length is bad in my opinion.

[silent_jonny]

Hello!! :)

Are you feeling better this week?

[38special]

Thank god it’s over!

[MagUSNRET]

One of my dads comments.....fitting in describing Caseys “DO”

SOn, did ya comb your hair with an egg beater?

[RummyChick]

supposedly Randy's shoes yesterday

[RummyChick]

[Shelayne]

ROFL! You even captured the same angle—perfect!

Though I always got such a kick out of Yukon Cornelius licking the snow off his pickaxe.

[MagUSNRET]

No offense to anyone who may be “slow”...but Randys look is more a “Remedial Pimp” look

[Netizen]

Purple hair and knee pads.

Do I dare ask???

[Shelayne]

WHAT is up with those jeans? *shudder*

[SilvieWaldorfMD]

SKYLAR IS SAFE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[EmilyGeiger]

You too. :) Finally I get to lurk around and laugh @ the comments on the thread.

[slugbug]

I knew there was no way that Skylar was going home! Why even put her in the bottom 3? She was there for what? 1 minute? Sheesh...

[MagUSNRET]

“Leggings for Losers”?

[Netizen]

His hair looks like a 2 month old bad perm. (and I know a bad perm!) lol

[RummyChick]

http://tvguide.ca/TVNews/Articles/120425_ryan_seacrest_diva_MH

"Not only does Ryan Seacrest have a high salary, but he’s also high-maintenance. So says Randy Jackson, the lone remaining original judge on American Idol of the Fox reality show’s host.
In an interview on Monday’s episode of CBS’s daytime chatfest The Talk, Jackson, who’s worked with Mariah Carey, Whitney Houston and Aretha Franklin, named Seacrest as the biggest diva he’s ever met. "

Oh, and there is more...

[silent_jonny]

Skylar and P2 appear next to Seacrest.

Iovine: (On Skylar's Queen song) Very competent. (On her second song) Self-indulgent. I don't think it cut the mustard.

(audience boos)

Iovine: (On P2's Queen song--he informs us that Phillips isn't feeling well ) It was missing something. (on the Dave Matthews song) A mistake. Very curious to see how the audience feels about this. I believe what he did left an opening for someone other than Phillip to be in the finale.

And Phillip is ... safe??

Skylar is in the bottom three.

Skylar Laine

But Seacrest grants her an instant reprieve.

Skylar is safe!

[Netizen]

Reverting back to childhood?

[twin2]

Are you feeling better this week? Yes, thank you:)

I just had to chase off the census people. After two months of me refusing to answer their survey on if I have flush toilets(!?), they came to my house in person. I told them I was busy with work on my computer. Thanks my FR friends, you are my excuse to lying to govt. agents:)

[RummyChick]

Oh my...Ryan is responsible for the Kardashians???

They just inked a huge deal.

Ryan must be raking in a lot of dough just from that..

[Netizen]

I think Randy’s look is a misguided scream for attention.

[Shelayne]

Jeggings for Jokers. ;^)

[silent_jonny]

Ther other singers have formed a protective cocoon around the Elise and Hollie. Seacrest has to break it up.

And the one going home is ...

Elise Testone