Suggest you review post 160. That’s what got a lot of discussion started. I’m still waiting on any Catholic to disavow that post as Catholic doctrine. So far none have.
I read post 160 and that is not Catholic doctrine. I guess everyone wants to keep arguing for the sake of arguing but that is not correct.
God has always been. Christ has always been. The Holy Spirit has always been. The Apostles Creed that we recite at every Mass we say Christ was begotten not made, one in being with the Father and through Him all things were made. It says by the power of the Holy Spirit HE CAME DOWN FROM HEAVEN, AND BECAME MAN.
He is I Am. None of the person’s of the Trinity were created, they have always been and will always be and that is what the Church teaches.