[verga]

Please try to follow the thread, we are discussing the syllogisms that non-Catholics refuse to answer, maybe you could have a go at since the others seem either unwilling or incapable.

Tell me which of the following syllogism are valid, and which are invalid. If you are capable of doing so, that will demonstrate that you can recognize the fallacy of the undistributed middle. If you can’t, you can’t.

A:

Dorothy is the mother of Sam.

Sam is a fireman.

Dorothy is the mother of a fireman.

B:

Evelyn is the mother of a fireman.

Gordon is a fireman.

Evelyn is the mother of Gordon.

C:

Mary is the mother of Jesus.

Jesus is God.

Mary is the mother of God.

D:

Mary is the Mother of God.

The Trinity is God.

Mary is the Mother of the Trinity.

[ealgeone]

How about this one?

Catholic sources admit there is no scriptural support for the immaculate conception.

Do catholics

a) disavow this false teaching?

b) continue to insist there is support for this false teaching?

[MHGinTN]

No, pigeon man, YOU are trying to discuss the half-baked syllogisms.

[Elsie]

Please try to follow the thread, we are discussing the syllogisms that non-Catholics refuse to answer, maybe you could have a go at since the others seem either unwilling or incapable.

We?

You and your pigeon friends?