Free Republic
Browse · Search
Religion
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

The Irrationality of Alcoholics Anonymous: Dozens of other treatments more effective.
The Atlantic ^ | 03/17/2015 | Gabrielle Glaser

Posted on 03/17/2015 9:25:29 AM PDT by SeekAndFind

[SNIP]

The 12 steps are so deeply ingrained in the United States that many people, including doctors and therapists, believe attending meetings, earning one’s sobriety chips, and never taking another sip of alcohol is the only way to get better. Hospitals, outpatient clinics, and rehab centers use the 12 steps as the basis for treatment. But although few people seem to realize it, there are alternatives, including prescription drugs and therapies that aim to help patients learn to drink in moderation. Unlike Alcoholics Anonymous, these methods are based on modern science and have been proved, in randomized, controlled studies, to work.

[SNIP]

The debate over the efficacy of 12-step programs has been quietly bubbling for decades among addiction specialists. But it has taken on new urgency with the passage of the Affordable Care Act, which requires all insurers and state Medicaid programs to pay for alcohol- and substance-abuse treatment, extending coverage to 32 million Americans who did not previously have it and providing a higher level of coverage for an additional 30 million.

Nowhere in the field of medicine is treatment less grounded in modern science. A 2012 report by the National Center on Addiction and Substance Abuse at Columbia University compared the current state of addiction medicine to general medicine in the early 1900s, when quacks worked alongside graduates of leading medical schools. The American Medical Association estimates that out of nearly 1 million doctors in the United States, only 582 identify themselves as addiction specialists. (The Columbia report notes that there may be additional doctors who have a subspecialty in addiction.) Most treatment providers carry the credential of addiction counselor or substance-abuse counselor, for which many states require little more than a high-school diploma or a GED. Many counselors are in recovery themselves.

(Excerpt) Read more at theatlantic.com ...


TOPICS: Current Events; General Discusssion; Moral Issues; Religion & Culture
KEYWORDS: aa; addiction; alcoholicsanonymous; alcoholism; naltrexone; obamacare
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 81-100101-120121-140141-157 last
To: Kickass Conservative

There is a difference bewteen a heavy drinker/problem drinker a bonafide alcoholic.

My experience has been heavy /problem drinkers and dyed in the wool alcoholics. The latter is addicted both physically and mentally. They cannot function without some level of alcohol in their system usally a minimun of .1 or better. Many long time drunks need significantly higher. They experience blackouts, severe insomnia, dramatic mood swings, and delusions when drinking particularly heavy.

Heavy/problem drinkers haven’t crossed the line into raging alcoholism but continued unabated they often do.

Binge drinkers are the exception. They are considered alcoholics because they possess many of the same characteristics of an “all the time” drunk but only drink for shorter durations 2-4 days. They do however tend to drink heavier during these periods often consuming in 3 days what a “Maintenance” alcoholic would in a week. Both types of alcoholics will definately destroy their life as they know it or likely die if some intervention is not initiated (By self or otherwise)

There’s often a fine line between problem/heavy drinker and an alcoholic. The only person who really knows is the person involved whether they are willing to admit it or not. Which makes a definitive diagnosis troublesome. My personal opinion is that there are fewer true alcoholics and more problem/heavy drinkers than generally accepted.


141 posted on 03/17/2015 9:12:20 PM PDT by traderrob6
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 140 | View Replies]

To: traderrob6
Growing up with an Alcoholic Father, the one thing I understood was that there is a direct correlation between Alcoholism and Narcissism.
142 posted on 03/17/2015 9:15:42 PM PDT by Kickass Conservative (Advertising Space Available here.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 141 | View Replies]

To: Kickass Conservative

Perhaps.

Oftentimes I’ve noticed alcoholics tend to have large egos combined with an inferiority complex. Sounds like an impossible combination but it most definately exists.


143 posted on 03/17/2015 9:20:55 PM PDT by traderrob6
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 142 | View Replies]

To: traderrob6

Feel free to search it yourself. documented many places.


144 posted on 03/18/2015 4:35:39 AM PDT by mad_as_he$$
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 132 | View Replies]

To: mad_as_he$$

One link would be plenty if you have one.


145 posted on 03/18/2015 5:11:56 AM PDT by traderrob6
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 144 | View Replies]

To: traderrob6

As all the “reputable research I’ve see states a range for AA of 30-40% year over year.

“In 1992 the United States Census Bureau and the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism (NIAAA) conducted the National Longitudinal Alcohol Epidemiologic Survey pegged AA at 31% so I’m interested to see your source(s).


146 posted on 03/18/2015 5:20:41 AM PDT by traderrob6
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 145 | View Replies]

To: mad_as_he$$

BTW, the 3 articles I found that support your conjecture.....2 from the Atlantic, 1 from Salon.

See a pattern there?


147 posted on 03/18/2015 5:25:56 AM PDT by traderrob6
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 144 | View Replies]

To: Vendome

Very true, and I forgot about that part. For a good friend of mine, he realized that certain triggers would lead to him drinking (going to a certain place, seeing certain people, etc). Removing those triggers removed much of the issue.

I honestly suspect that addiction has more to do with how your brain is wired than anything else. My friend has an addictive personality. Once it engages, it is scary. Right now he is turned “on” by Game of War. He spends 30 hours a week on it. It used to be smoking, booze, or sex.


148 posted on 03/18/2015 7:06:40 AM PDT by redgolum ("God is dead" -- Nietzsche. "Nietzsche is dead" -- God.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 135 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind
People with no sense of history should refrain "removing all doubt" about their being qualified to comment on matters they clearly do not understand.

For starters, what youngsters fail to understand is what a physician's diagnosis of "dypsomania" meant for anyone before 1935. For most patients, no all but certainly most, it was a sentence of death. Bill Wilson and Dr. Bob, with the Oxford Group developed a way that works. It's a way that worked for many millions of people who otherwise faced death, prison or institutionalization as their only choice.

More importantly perhaps in the context of this unnecessary thesis, Bill Wilson could not have been more clear about alternative treatments and methods. In his "Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions" he insisted their Fellowship should never be critical of any alternative treatment methods, then or in the future, and he never, never claimed an exclusive working method.

It's unfortunate that the strong admonition "rarely have we seen a person fail who has thoroughly followed our path" added to the zeal passed on to newcomers to pursue a new life devoted to "rigorous honesty" is often either misinterpreted or misunderstood.

There are also many who really believe there is no other paths, an opinion which is a departure from the path passed along by Bill W. and Dr. Bob., "one drunk helping another stay sober, one day at a time."

There is also always the unfortunate tendency of all institutions to drift from their primary objective, their "reason for being" becoming, over time, displaced by self-continuity. The capacity for direct personal gain from AA is slight to none, so this latter hardening of tradition into dusty orthodoxy is rare with "the program," but it there, nonetheless, most especially when unauthorized mercenary purposes presume an affiliation.

Nevertheless, the notion that AA is in competition with other methods is specious. The Traditions of this simple and originally novel rehabilitation program, which has never claimed to be a "cure," make clear that any method that interrupts the "cunning, baffling, powerful" compulsion to drink oneself to death is not just welcome but encouraged.

149 posted on 03/18/2015 7:45:32 AM PDT by Prospero (Si Deus trucido mihi, ego etiam fides Deus.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: redgolum

I have two primary addictions:

I crave food and can never get enough air.


150 posted on 03/18/2015 8:29:36 AM PDT by Vendome (Don't take life so seriously-you won't live through it anyway-Enjoy Yourself ala Louis Prima)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 148 | View Replies]

To: Vendome

Seriously, the vast majority of Americans are addicted to something.

Food (in excess), work, sex, alcohol, drugs, thrill seeking, internet, shopping, gambling you name it.

With my wife it’s diet Coke.

Basically there are positive addictions which often lead to noteworthy accomplishment and the negative ones which lead to self destruction and death.

The key for those with a “negative” addiction is to replace it with either a positive or at least a benign one.


151 posted on 03/18/2015 11:09:14 AM PDT by traderrob6
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 150 | View Replies]

To: Prospero
Nevertheless, the notion that AA is in competition with other methods is specious. The Traditions of this simple and originally novel rehabilitation program, which has never claimed to be a "cure," make clear that any method that interrupts the "cunning, baffling, powerful" compulsion to drink oneself to death is not just welcome but encouraged.

I think some people just like to disagree, and feel it necessary to try to prove others wrong. We see it in politics, sports, business, etc. Just human nature, I suppose.

As you mentioned, the Traditions should be a firm guide as to how AA approaches outside opinions or controversies. Yet, I think the Traditions are an under utilized facet of the program. Unfortunate, really, as it contains useful instructions on how to live comfortably in the world around us.

AA service was critical in helping me develop a way for me to live with responsibility and without anger, and as my sponsor would remind me, how to disagree without being disagreeable. I don't know that I always achieve that goal, but it is a constant desire.

152 posted on 03/18/2015 11:25:35 AM PDT by Repealthe17thAmendment
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 149 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

Thank you for this post. I have tried explaining these facts to people but the AA method is so entrenched I am met with outright skepticism. Yes AA does work for some but it is not the cure all it is depicted to be. This should be of concern especially to the court system that often mandate AA and other 12 step programs as a condition of meeting probation. Sending people to a program with a high failure rate is just bad policy and other programs need to be optioned.


153 posted on 03/18/2015 11:04:51 PM PDT by lastchance (Credo.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: lastchance

“Yes AA does work for some but it is not the cure all it is depicted to be”

Please iilustrate where anyone depicts AA to be a “cure all”

On this forum or any anywhere else for that matter.


154 posted on 03/19/2015 5:06:04 AM PDT by traderrob6
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 153 | View Replies]

To: traderrob6

Sometimes I really have to scratch my head and wonder what could possibly be the motivation or agenda that would lead people to chastize a program that costs the taxpayers (or anyone else) nothing, is completely voluntary, is totally apolitical, turns NO one away, and has helped and continues to help millions recover from what often used to be considered a death sentence.

AA certainly is not a “cure all” and absolutely has never represented itself as such. It does however offer a relatively good opportunity for a recovering alcoholic to maintain long term sobriety.

It has arguably proven to be as effective as most and more so than some programs aiding in the recovery from substance abuse. Most reputable estimates put year over year success rates between 30-40%.

I am sure there are other programs out there that can boast of similar rates of outcome, maybe even better. I applaud those acheivements.

But what truely is dangerous are the multitude of schemes that have been around for years that tend to cost a lot of money and promise cures. If anyone had a “cure” there sucess rate would be 100% and presently there is NO program at any cost that can honestly boast anything remotely close to that.

Yes, spirtuality (God) is a an integral part of the AA progaram and that is offputting to some. If so, there are plenty of secular alternatives.

The bottom line is this and AA believes it wholeheartedly....”whatever works for you”.


155 posted on 03/19/2015 6:23:09 AM PDT by traderrob6
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 154 | View Replies]

To: Repealthe17thAmendment
how to disagree without being disagreeable

Sounds like we're on similar paths. May you find your trail as agreeable. It's amazing how these small statements which are heard more or less constantly in Discussion Meetings can slip the mind, like "how to disagree" or, similarly, "don't sweat the small stuff..." Meanwhile, something I heard one of "the old-timers" say nearly forty years ago in a meeting still has me chewing over it.

The topic was How Are Things Different Today, or words to that effect. And the guy who's name I can't remember, God knows, said, simply, "there aren't any big deals, anymore."

Can't say I agreed completely even now, but I think I understood what he meant.

One of the things that has helped me, over and over, is reading (and re-reading) Psalm 27.

I still haven't "resigned from the debating society," as Bill Wilson recommended in "the Twelve and Twelve," but seeing less and less civilized debate, the use of hatred and anger as a unifying agent in mass movements and its use as a deliberate distraction in tactics of war has left very damn few opportunities for productive debate.

Grace and Peace...

156 posted on 03/19/2015 7:55:13 AM PDT by Prospero (Si Deus trucido mihi, ego etiam fides Deus.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 152 | View Replies]

To: traderrob6

The people in this forum certainly have not done so and have been very forthright with how AA has worked for them and not for others.

However AA is still largely promoted as being the only game in town for dealing with alcohol addiction and drinking problems by many social service agencies, courts, counselors and others who may not be aware that AA and other such programs are not going to work for every alcoholic.

Not everybody who has a drinking problem has it for the same reason and it is important to treat addiction as the multi faceted problem that it is. AA plays a very important and successful role in that treatment but for some it is not enough.


157 posted on 03/19/2015 10:09:29 AM PDT by lastchance (Credo.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 154 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 81-100101-120121-140141-157 last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Religion
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson