[2nd amendment mama]

I never denied that...they were baptized Catholic...nothing else possible...and they choose to follow another Christian denomination.....but they were all once Catholic.....you can't be Baptized Lutheran.....doesn't work that way.

Now you're telling a Catholic Priest that he's wrong! Just which seminary did you graduate from? What was your degree in? Catholic Priest vs Catholic who thinks that they know it all...

They were NOT all Catholic at one time! And yes, you can be baptized Lutheran, Episcopal, Baptist, etc.

[Crim]

“And yes, you can be baptized Lutheran, Episcopal, Baptist, etc.”

Holy water comes in flavors now?....who knew?

[terycarl]

They were NOT all Catholic at one time! And yes, you can be baptized Lutheran, Episcopal, Baptist, etc.

No you can't....you can be baptized in a Lutheran church, an Episcopal church, a Baptist church, in a hospital, in a bedroom right after birth if necessary, on a bus, in an auto....it doesn't matter at all where you were baptized nor by who....I can do it, you can do it, the Pope can do it...it is all the same....If you were validly baptized, you were baptized Catholic....there can be no other way.