I would argue then that they aren't Catholic at all. It is one thing to commit mortal sins. It is quite another to be in favor of/encourage mortal sins.
For every 50 Dolans you have one Cardinal Burke! And that my friend is what is wrong with the American Catholic Church. Live the faith the way you know it is meant to be lived and please don’t look for spiritual guidance from democrat operatives, and that’s what most American bishops have become, led by Dolan, who should be ashamed of himself for his many anti-Catholic actions.
A good many of them are apostates. Arguably, Dolan has apostatized. How many times can a person assert that pro-abortion people are good Catholics without being an apostate? Dolan has made such statements about David Paterson and Andrew Cuomo.