[Religion Moderator]

The issue here is only how to avoid disruption on threads labeled "Catholic Caucus." From the Religion Forum guidelines:

Caucus labels exist only for the purpose of avoiding unwanted disruptions on Religion Forum threads. The terms used in a caucus label are not necessarily precise with reference to Canon Law, theology or even dictionaries – but are intended to communicate briefly who should or should not post on a thread.

[Legatus]

The issue here is only how to avoid disruption on threads labeled "Catholic Caucus."

With respect, that isn't going to be possible, believe it or not sometimes people will disagree for the sheer sake of disagreeing... especially Catholics. If you suppress disruption in caucus threads by members of the caucus you'll end up stifling discussion. I suppose there could be a Novus Ordo caucus and a traddy caucus but that just seems silly.