[daniel1212]

One can not say Scripture is inerrant, but somebody's interpretation can not be inerrant, unless the person saying so claims inerrancy. Such a person commits the same act they criticize the Catholic Church for, but simply isn't smart enough to recognize that fact.

Jumping into a thread i have not been following recently, but did you mean to say “one can say Scripture is inerrant?” The “but” seems to be making a distinction.

[papertyger]

... did you mean to say “one can say Scripture is inerrant?”

No.

[papertyger]

The “but” seems to be making a distinction.

My point in the sentence you ask about is you can not claim both the first clause AND the second clause without the third clause being true.