Posted on 12/18/2002 5:30:16 PM PST by backhoe
Edited on 12/18/2002 5:45:05 PM PST by Admin Moderator. [history]
Announcement from Managers of Adriana Stuijt's "journalism during apartheid "site | |
Reply US might invade South Africa - claim by health minister
- http://www.news24.com/News24/South_Africa/News/0,1113,2-7-1442_1299228,00.html
Dec 18 2002 -- South Africa's aids-denialist health minister Manto Tshabala-Msimang claims she never said that "South Africa could be invaded by the US; that Africa's southern-most country 'not afford anti-Aids drugs, because it needed submarines to deter attacks from nations such as the United States.'However, the highly-respected journalist of The Guardian newspaper who had quoted her as saying this, sticks by the story --- saying that he had reported her comments totally accurately during his conversation with the minister.
Britain's Guardian newspaper reported on Tuesday that budgetary priorities meant the health department could not provide antiretroviral (ARV) drugs to the estimated 4.5 million South Africans with HIV."We don't have the money for that. Where would it come from," Tshabalala-Msimang was quoted as saying.
Asked if it could come from the money earmarked for the submarines which form part of the multi-billion arms deal, Tshabala-Msimang then said "South Africa needed to deter aggressors: "Look at what Bush is doing. He could invade."Tshabalala-Msimang said in response that " the media had a responsibility not to sow confusion about Aids."
She also dismissed claims by the Treatment Action Campaign that she had scuppered high-level negotiations for a national antiretroviral treatment plan.
The Cape Times reported on Wednesday that the minister had not yet signed an agreement reached at National Economic Development Labour Council, the forum where intensive discussions had been held for several months among government, labour and business about an HIV/Aids plan that includes ARVs.
"How can I sign a draft agreement? (Labour) Minister Mdladlana and I have to see the final product and then still take it to Cabinet."Fiddles while SA burns
On the TAC's concerns that the department had not yet released a report compiled by South Africa's top HIV/Aids researchers that recommended ARV treatment, she said the report had still to be discussed at Minmec, the forum consisting of the national health and provincial departments.
On the threatened court action against Mpumalanga health MEC Sibongile Manana for allegedly failing to provide nevirapine to pregnant women, Tshabala-Msimang said the TAC was entitled to their action.
However, she was aware that Mpumalanga had bought enough ARVs to be dispensed at those public hospitals with the necessary capacity.
Tshabalala-Msimang's comments in the Guardian provoked criticism from some opposition parties on Wednesday.
Tshabalala-Msimang was providing the villain in a tragi-comic Christmas pantomime, the Democratic Alliance said on Wednesday. "She continues to fiddle while South Africa burns," DA Chief Whip Douglas Gibson said in a statement.
United Democratic Movement spokesperson Pieter van Pletzen said Tshabalala-Msimang's alleged preference for arms over ARVs confirmed the government had "sold out" South Africans."Clearly the ANC has declared war on innocent South Africans, and by her own admission prefer to let people die.
"The UDM regards her utterances as disgusting," he said in a statement.In a separate statement, Afrikaner Eenheidsbeweging (AEB) leader Cassie Aucampalso said Tshabalala-Msimang's comments were "totally irresponsible". Statements such as this were not only totally unfounded, but could kill President Thabo Mbeki's initiatives for an African renaissance and foreign investment in the New Partnership for Africa's Development."The AEB calls on Mr Mbeki to do some damage control and repudiate what Tshabalala-Msimang has said." He warned against the development of an "anti-US culture within the ANC".
- Aucamp said the AEB had serious doubts about the health minister's view of international politics, and advised the public health official (who has no medical qualifications -- she has a Belgian university degree in social welfare) "to rather stick with her stethoscope". http://www.news24.com/News24/South_Africa/News/0,1113,2-7-1442_1299228,00.htm
- Mandela slams US President -- yet still denies people's rights to criticise Namibian president
- http://www.anc.org.za/briefing/index.html
December 17 2002 at 04:46PM
Nobel Peace Laureate and retired SA President Nelson Mandela -- a man who said this week he may never die -- this week lambasted the United States on Tuesday for what he said were efforts to sideline the United Nations and condemned the Americans' grab for an Iraq weapons dossier as "piracy".
"I am disappointed with heads of state who are just keeping quiet when the United States wants to sideline the United Nations," he said at the African National Congress's five-yearly conference, being held in Stellenbosch in the Western Cape.
The latest move, providing evidence for what Mandela says is the dangerous US disregard for the principles of multi-lateral world governance, was the arrival of Iraq's 12 000-page weapons declaration dossier in Washington earlier this month.
'This was an act of piracy which must be condemned by everyone'
Washington obtained an early unedited copy of the Iraqi declaration originally sent to the United Nations after a deal was struck to override a UN Security Council decision to keep the report under wraps at UN headquarters in New York.
"This was an act of piracy which must be condemned by everyone," Mandela said.
Iraq blasted the move and also said "the US would manipulate the dossier to produce a pretext to launch war.
Mandela, 84, said both he and current South African President Thabo Mbeki counted themselves as friends of the United States and of President George W Bush. But Mandela has been a fierce critic of US policy towards Iraq.
"And one must not be dishonest and evade the real issue - that the US has tended to dangerously disregard the principles of multi-lateral world governance," he said.
"The conduct of the US and the Bush administration with regards to the current Iraq issue is a case in point."
Mandela said there was a clear impression that the US "remained intent on military action against Iraq at all costs".However, while Mandela was lambasting the democratically-elected US president, he also claimed that day that " outsiders" were not allowed to criticize his friend Sam Nujoma, the president of Namibia -- because he had been " democratically elected."
Mandela said in Stellenbosch according to the SA Press Association:
"People outside Namibia should not complain about Namibian President Sam Nujoma's third term in office, former president Nelson Mandela said on Tuesday.
If he has been elected by his comrades in a free and fair election, we as foreigners have no right to complain," he told delegates at the African National Congress' 51st conference in Stellenbosch.South Africa was a close friend of the US, both free and democratic countries of the world. He had strong personal bonds with President George W Bush, he claimed.
"I've found him to be objective, open-minded and honest." Mbeki shared that opinion, Mandela said.Bush had given him many awards, and he had been invited to visit former president George Bush, the incumbent's father, in Texas.
"(Despite) the fact that he has given me awards, I'm sure the US does not want me to suppress my view. I'll continue to express it."
Mandela was "confident that the ANC would dominate South Africa's politics for years to come.Mandela: I don't know if I'll ever to die...
"I don't know if I'll ever die. There is that possibility,' he said in his speech.
"If that happens I'll move to the next world... and the first thing I'll look for will be the nearest branch of the ANC."
source: gopher://gopher.anc.org.za/00/anc/newsbrief/2002/news1218
processed Tue 17 Dec 2002 08:48 SAST.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.