Malaysia canes illegal immigrants!

BBC ^ | Saturday, 10 August, 2002, 07:01 GMT 08:01 UK | Editorial Staff

[vannrox]

Saturday, 10 August, 2002, 07:01 GMT 08:01 UK

Malaysia canes illegal immigrants

Many illegal migrants work in the construction industry


Malaysian courts have ordered seven illegal immigrants to be jailed and caned in the first cases to be tried under the country's tough new immigration laws. Seven men, aged between 22 and 38, were convicted of staying in Malaysia without valid documents under legislation which came into effect at the end of July.

Indonesians protested against the new laws


Four Indonesians were sentenced to two stokes of the cane. Another Indonesian and two Bangladeshis were ordered to be whipped once.

The seven were also sentenced to jail terms of between six months and two years. They will all be deported after serving their sentences.

The migrants are the first to be tried under a new law which stipulates that foreign workers without relevant permits, and anyone who employs or harbours them, can be fined up to 10,000 ringgit ($2,600), imprisoned for five years and given up to six strokes of the cane.

Amnesty period

The law came into force after a four-month grace period during which illegal immigrants could leave the country freely with no questions asked.

An estimated 300,000 people left Malaysia under the amnesty programme


But government officials say only half the country's estimated 600,000 illegal immigrants, mainly Indonesians, left the country under this amnesty programme.

The sentences against the seven men were handed out by courts in the central state of Selangor and the northern island state of Penang on Friday, officials told the Associated Press news agency.

The immigration director of central Selangor state, Che Mamat Abdullah, told the Bernama news agency that a further 13 cases would be brought to court next week, while another 37 cases were currently under investigation.

Employment shortages

Employers and manufacturers have warned that mass deportations could hit the economy hard, as it relies heavily on foreign workers to do jobs that many locals refuse to do.

Most immigrants are employed in menial plantation, construction or housekeeping jobs.


Property developers say they may suffer serious losses because of a labour shortage, while thousands of hawkers and petty traders may have to close as a result of the crackdown.

Malaysia is one of South East Asia's wealthiest countries and acts as a magnet for migrants fleeing poverty and violence in the rest of the region.


On Thursday, Malaysia and Indonesia failed to reach agreement on the fate of illegal migrants.

Speaking in Bali after a meeting with Indonesian President Megawati Sukarnoputri, Malaysian Prime Minister Dr Mahathir Mohamad said that unemployed foreigners were partly responsible for Malaysia's crime problems.


Malaysia also blames the immigrants for contributing to a growth in social unrest, citing two riots by Indonesian workers earlier this year.

[vannrox]

Hum. California and Texas... Opinions?

[Nachum]

Tempting, very tempting.

Naahhh, they'd probably start caning people for traffic tickets too.

[norraad]

cool

[Kaslin]

The way I feel is that the illegals should be caned here to along with the Employers who hire them, knowing they are illegals

[Amerigomag]

Finally, a country that esteems its culture, follows the rule of law, and enforces it's sovereignty.

Any chance Washington gets the message? Nah.

[dougherty]

I would love to see us follow their example. Enough is enough.

[glc1173@aol.com]

Right now, the only people a government agency in the U.S. beats is schoolchildren in government schools who throw spitballs, talk back to teachers, etc.

Something is very wrong when U.S. agencies punish America's own children worse than illegal invaders!

Get the sticker!