Sharon calls for immediate construction of "separation" fence

israelinsider ^ | 04/14 16:15 | israelinsider

[FITZ]

I'm not sure why 118 got pulled ---I don't think it should matter if the Jews are genetically pure semetics --- or the same as the people there 1000 years ago. It's not about ethnicity anyhow ---if a group of Palestinians converted to Judaism, the others would start killing them for being Jewish.

[rmvh]

re your # 121.... I'm not sure why 118 got pulled ---I don't think it should matter if the Jews are genetically pure semetics --- or the same as the people there 1000 years ago. It's not about ethnicity anyhow ---if a group of Palestinians converted to Judaism, the others would start killing them for being Jewish.

What you say is partly true.....It has now escalated to the point ( because of the tactics of "The Corrpulant one" to the point where any Jew is a target no matter what their genetic heritage might be.

However, you miss the point that genetic heritage does matter in the larger scheme of things. Well over 90% of Israeli Jews have absolutely no connection to the holy Land other than their religion which might in turn have been aquired in their family200 years ago....All Jews use the term anti-semitism as a fig leaf to cover the fact that the Russian and Polish Jews really have no heritage to justify their massive occupation and take-over of Palestine since 1946. Such a "fig leaf", of course, does not apply to the semetic Jews whose families have lived their for well over 3,500 years.

[driftless]

And of course you have proof that all the Palestinians involved have been living on the land for thousands of years and none of them have migrated there through the centuries.

Your argument is meretricious.

[Caipirabob]

Sharon calls for immediate construction of "separation" fence.

These Israelis need better "marketing tactics".

Call it a "PEACE FENCE".

[sleavelessinseattle]

Ping!

[rmvh]

Re your # 123.....Your argument is meretricious.

Really nice word! I like it.

But it really isn't my argument...or even an argument of or by anyone.

Try the Encyclopedia Britanica or the Americana for the historical facts on the history of Palestine.....The information there is not written by religious fanatics or Jewish Apologists. Its just a factual summary for those wishing to learn. At the same time, these encyclopedias, among other non-sectarian sources, might help you avoid misunderstanding historical reality based on biblical mysticism.

Please have a very nice day.

[mmmmmmmm....... donuts]

It's a little obscene comparing the entire West Bank to a prison camp. Having snipers to keep Palestinians out certainly won't present an endearing image, but could be effective. Come here, and die; stay out, and live. That's essentially how the Palestinians feel about the Israelis anyway, so why not have it work in both directions?

[colorado tanker]

Thanks for the ping! I enjoyed JasonC's essays on WWII armor even more than the topic of the thread!

[sleavelessinseattle]

Then my job here is done|*}