Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: Kalamata
Denier Kalamata: " On the other hand, there is little doubt that Hitler and his education chief were heavily influenced by Darwinism, as were the other 20th century butchers. "

Nonsense, the fact is that Hitler never mentioned Darwin, natural selection or evolution as natural selection in Mein Kampf.
He did claim to have first learned anti-Semitism in the anti-Semetic Christian Workers Party.
By his own telling of it, Hitler came to anti-Semitism through politics not science.

In reality, there were other strong influences as well, but none had anything to do with Darwin.
So blaming Darwin for the Holocaust is like blaming 9/11 on the breakfast those terrorists ate.

388 posted on 09/12/2019 2:31:52 PM PDT by BroJoeK ((a little historical perspective...))
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 331 | View Replies ]


To: BroJoeK
>>Denier Kalamata: "On the other hand, there is little doubt that Hitler and his education chief were heavily influenced by Darwinism, as were the other 20th century butchers. "
>>History Denier Joey said: "Nonsense, the fact is that Hitler never mentioned Darwin, natural selection or evolution as natural selection in Mein Kampf.

This is Hitler's Mein Kampf on natural selection:

"Under certain circumstances, in periods of distress or under bad climatic condition, or if the soil yields too poor a return, Nature herself tends to check the increase of population in some countries and among some races, but by a method which is quite as ruthless as it is wise. It does not impede the procreative faculty as such; but it does impede the further existence of the offspring by submitting it to such tests and privations that everything which is less strong or less healthy is forced to retreat into the bosom of tile unknown. Whatever survives these hardships of existence has been tested and tried a thousandfold, hardened and renders fit to continue the process of procreation; so that the same thorough selection will begin all over again. By thus dealing brutally with the individual and recalling him the very moment he shows that he is not fitted for the trials of life, Nature preserves the strength of the race and the species and raises it to the highest degree of efficiency." [Adolf Hitler, "Mein Kampf." Hurst and Blackett Ltd., 1939, pp.112-113]

This is Hitler' Mein Kampf on the evolution of man:

"Only after subjugated races were employed as slaves was a similar fate allotted to animals, and not vice versa, as some people would have us believe. At first it was the conquered enemy who had to draw the plough and only afterwards did the ox and horse take his place. Nobody else but puling pacifists can consider this fact as a sign of human degradation. Such people fail to recognize that this evolution had to take place in order that man might reach that degree of civilization which these apostles now exploit in an attempt to make the world pay attention to their rigmarole." [Adolf Hitler, "Mein Kampf." Hurst and Blackett Ltd., 1939, pp.222-223]

"The favourable preliminary to this improvement is not to mate individuals of higher and lower orders of being but rather to allow the complete triumph of the higher order. The stronger must dominate and not mate with the weaker, which would signify the sacrifice of its own higher nature. Only the born weakling can look upon this principle as cruel, and if he does so it is merely because he is of a feebler nature and narrower mind; for if such a law did not direct the process of evolution then the higher development of organic life would not be conceivable at all." [Adolf Hitler, "Mein Kampf." Hurst and Blackett Ltd., 1939, p.222.223]

Hitler didn't simply name-drop natural selection and evolution, Joey; he lived it!

***********************

>>History Denier Joey said: "He did claim to have first learned anti-Semitism in the anti-Semetic Christian Workers Party.

I have never heard of the Christian Workers Party, Joey. I have heard of the Christian Social Workers Party which was a left-wing Socialist organization that supposedly disbanded in the early 1900's. You cannot be a Christian and be a socialist, Joey; so don't be fooled by a label.

***********************

>>History Denier Joey said: "By his own telling of it, Hitler came to anti-Semitism through politics not science."

That may be true, Joey, but where are your references?

***********************

>>History Denier Joey said: "In reality, there were other strong influences as well, but none had anything to do with Darwin. So blaming Darwin for the Holocaust is like blaming 9/11 on the breakfast those terrorists ate.

Dr. Jerry Bergman, a Jew, disagrees with you, Joey:

"Although it is no easy task to assess the conflicting motives of Hitler and his supporters, Darwinism-inspired eugenics clearly played a critical role. Darwinism justified and encouraged the Nazi views on both race and war. If the Nazi party had fully embraced and consistently acted on the belief that all humans were descendants of Adam and Eve and equal before the creator God, as taught in both the Old Testament and New Testament Scriptures, the holocaust would never have occurred. Expunging of the Judeo-Christian doctrine of the divine origin of humans from mainline German (liberal) theology and its schools, and replacing it with Darwinism, openly contributed to the acceptance of Social Darwinism that culminated in the tragedy of the holocaust. Darwin's theory, as modified by Haeckel, Chamberlain and others, clearly contributed to the death of over nine million people in concentration camps, and about 40 million other humans in a war that cost about six trillion dollars. Furthermore, the primary reason that Nazism reached to the extent of the holocaust was the widespread acceptance of Social Darwinism by the scientific and academic community." [Jerry Bergman, "Darwinism And The Nazi Race Holocaust." Talk Origins, Aug 13, 1999]

"Terms such as 'superior race', 'lower human types', 'pollution of the race', and the word evolution itself (Entwicklung) were often used by Hitler and other Nazi leaders. His race views were not from fringe science as often claimed but rather Hitler's views were [quoting George Stein]: " … straightforward German social Darwinism of a type widely known and accepted throughout Germany and which, more importantly, was considered by most Germans, scientists included, to be scientifically true. More recent scholarship on national socialism and Hitler has begun to realize that … [their application of Darwin's theory] was the specific characteristic of Nazism. National socialist 'biopolicy,' … [was] a policy based on a mystical-biological belief in radical inequality, a monistic, anti-transcendent moral nihilism based on the eternal struggle for existence and the survival of the fittest as the law of nature, and the consequent use of state power for a public policy of natural selection…'" [Ibid.]

This is Stein's quote in full so you can examine the context:

"There is no originality here, crazy or otherwise. Hitler's views are rather straightforward German social Darwinism of a type widely known and accepted throughout Germany and which, more importantly, was considered by most Germans, scientists included, to be scientifically true. More recent scholarship on national socialism and Hitler has begun to realize that this"crazy originality" was the specific characteristic of Nazism. National socialist "biopolicy," a policy based on a mystical-biological belief in racial inequality, a monistic, anti-transcendent moral nihilism based on the eternal struggle for existence and the survival of the fittest as the law of nature, and the consequent use of state power for a public policy of natural selection, is what national socialism is all about (Jackel 1972). Once it becomes clear that a particular biopolicy was the basis of the regime, various historical problems such as the seeming inconsistency or opportunism of tactics, the strategic blunders such as the invasion of Russia, or the totally irrational efforts expended on the extermination of undesirables become clear." [George J. Stein, "Biological Science and the Roots of Nazism." American Scientist, Vol.76, Iss.1; January, 1988, p.51]

Mr. Kalamata

403 posted on 09/13/2019 1:47:49 PM PDT by Kalamata (BIBLE RESEARCH TOOLS: http://bibleresearchtools.com/)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 388 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson