[PapaBear3625]

How could she know (or remember) who these “boys” were?

It would be one thing if they were classmates whom she saw every day. But that was not the case. She would be remembering a boy she met once at a party decades ago. How would she have remembered his name after decades?

[independentmind]

I think that Kavanaugh was a star athlete in high school. Lots of girls remember guys like that.