Not a believable story. Most people who live outside a cardboard box know that Key West is very very very gay.
Here are some hotels not to stay at:
http://gaytravel.about.com/od/keywestgaytravel/tp/Key-West-Gay-Hotels-Guide.htm.
My family has property/time shares in KW. The Hyatt is NOT a gay resort as this article says.
Oh, the horror of being there the week of Halloween. They wore the most lewd costumes in broad daylight and there wasn’t even a parade.