Thank you for the history lesson, I am a Christian Zionist Conservative myself. However, I do stand on what I said. You can identify yourself however you wish, but that does not make it so. Those “Jews” that are not observant and substitute the God of Marx to the God of Moses, are hostile to the state of Israel and sympathetic to their enemies that work for its destruction cannot be called true Jews, but false ones. I will apply the same definition to Christians who worship debauchery and Social(ist) Justice as equally fake.
You are welcome.
Well you laid out your religious-political definition for what constitutes a “Jew” or “Christian”. Of course you are enrirled to your own criteria.
“You can identify yourself however you wish, but that does not make it so.”
Self-identification of course alone is insufficient.
But when Jewish and Israeli law say that someone is Jewish by blood, then that person certainly can claim to be Jewish.