Your opinion only.
Since the Catholic church has never taken action against them and continues to allow them to participate in the church and partake of the sacraments, then they Catholic church considers them *real* Catholics, your opinion and other FRoman opinions notwithstanding.
wow- you really are ignorant..I’ve been to a lot of masses where the Catholic church has asked from the pulpit to stop abortion...i’ve been to pro-life walks where Catholic priests have been in attendance...they undertook an unprecedented “Fortnight for Freedom” against obama’s policies two years ago (http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/maryland/bs-md-fortnight-of-freedom-20120621-story.html)
should they require everyone to bring voting history cards with them?