I reject your framing of the argument - “You can’t have it both ways... You can’t cherry pick...”
Of course I can choose to comment on certain aspects of Trump’s approach, and leave others behind.
As far as voting for “H. Clinton,” only brain-dead liberals, fools, gibsmedats and traitors would do that.
I don’t think he should keep his mouth shut.
The above is what you stated, not I. In one breath you tell Trump to keep his mouth shut and don't respond to the lying corrupt media. In the next breath you don't want him to keep his mouth shut regarding the lying corrupt media.
Ya can't have it both ways slick. That's not the way it works. If you'd like, I can repeat this half a dozen more times for you.☺