One second they are reporting that Secret Service is counseling the Trump campaign, out an abundance of caution in case some nutcase take the remark as incitement. Literally 10 seconds later the panel comes in and argues that of course the remark was incitement.
Sometime between midnight and 12:30 eastern, for those who grab transcripts when they become available.
Joe Biden directly threatened Barack Obama.
The you tube capture of——CNNs-——clip can be found by
searching for Biden and Beretta 2008.