Posted on 06/26/2015 8:49:52 AM PDT by SeekAndFind
Reducing Pope Francis’s encyclical “Laudato Si” to a white paper on global warming is, in George Weigel’s fitting analogy, “akin to reading ‘Moby Dick’ as if it were a treatise on the 19th-century New England whaling industry.” The whole spirit and story of the thing are missed.
The pope’s sprawling, ambitious statement — setting out a theory of nature and of the human person — will be profitably scrutinized for decades. Environmentalists who like some of Francis’s conclusions will find, if they sit quietly with the text rather than rummage through it for the politically relevant bits, that the pope is making a frontal assault on a technological and utilitarian worldview that treats creation as “raw material to be hammered into useful shape,” reduces humans to mere consumers and treats inconvenient people as so much refuse.
SNIP
Many conservative Republicans now deny the existence or danger of human-caused warming and routinely question the motives of scientists who speak up on the issue. For a conservative to stray from skepticism is regarded as ideological betrayal.
In a recent National Affairs essay, Jim Manzi and Peter Wehner provide an explanation: “The Republican position — either avowed ignorance or conspiracy theorizing — is ultimately unsustainable, but some still cling to it because they believe that accepting the premise that some climate change is occurring as a result of human action means accepting the conclusions of the most rabid left-wing climate activists. They fear, at least implicitly, that the politics of climate change is just a twisted road with a known destination . . . ceding yet another key economic sector to government control.”
This is the temptation of the ideologically intense on the left and right: Truth exists to serve the narrative rather than the narrative arising from truth.
(Excerpt) Read more at washingtonpost.com ...
Why not? We’re getting our asses handed to us on every other issue that matters.
The earth has been warming and cooling for 4 billion years.
Get over it, Mike.
Newspapers have a huge carbon footprint.
Agreed.
Next the SCOTUS will rule that a 10% flat “climate change” tax surcharge executive order is enforceable.
The first Americans were shooting over a 2% tax on tea. You don’t think Obama is thinking about it?
I want real evidence. Until the I am a skeptic.
Dint ding! Winner!
For all conservatives supposed support of “big business,” big business has been the most effective enforcer of left position in the last ten years. We only have gay marriage today because big business enforced it. Climate change is being pushed by big business.
The article is published in WaPo, but it was written by Michael Gerson, who was a speech writer for George Bush.
As for SCOTUS, they have all ready handed down three important decisions on CO2:
Massachusetts v EPA(2007)
AEP v Connecticut(2011)
Utility Air Regulatory Group v EPA(2014)
In August, EPA will issue their final rule on Obama's Clean Power Plan and there will be lawsuits filed over that, which will have to ultimately be ruled on by SCOTUS.
In the 2007 decision(5-4), SCOTUS ruled that CO2 was a pollutant, and if EPA found CO2 to be a threat to the US(endangerment finding), then EPA should regulate CO2 with the Clean Air Act.
A speech writer opining on a scientific subject. Appeals to authority have been the hallmark of those who lack the ability to judge the science.
What he says is true.
Being against homosexuality is hate speech.
Criticizing people who are men calling themselves women, or white people calling themselves black, or Caucasians calling themselves Native American is hate speech.
Being against all racism including black racism is hate speech.
Objecting to throwing the Confederate flag down the memory hole is not only hate speech, it is open advocacy of killing people in a church.
Why should people who criticize the global warming religion be any different?
If by accident we are on our way to an ice age, it will just make the ice age that much worse and millions will starve. But since they will mostly be the poor and those in 3rd worlds, well, they should have spoken up.
This would be an all or nothing basis, put lives on the line those of you who feel so strongly in global warming.
As a rich American, I have a buying opportunity when the population of many 3rd world countries dies and there is no one left to pay taxes on land or support corrupt governments.
Let's get on with it. (/sarcasm)
The victory dance of the Emperor with “New” Clothes.
They’ll put a gun to your head and demand you embrace their religion.
Meh. I’ll bet Mike is grateful that projection is a painless process.
It is time for the entire world to have a FACTUAL discussion about the climate, rather than a Leftist purge of those who disagree with the fashion of the moment (which, not-so-coincidentally, happens to lead to the concentration of wealth and power in the hands of those who are doing the purging).
I hope that I live long enough to see the District of Criminals buried in 10 feet of snow during a “Global Warming” conference.
Same guys who wanted to torture Galileo and Copernicus for their outrageous and anti Science view that the earth and other planets revolved around the sun rather than the reverse.
We need an assault on a technological and Totalitarian worldview that treats humans as “raw material to be hammered into useful shape,” and reduces humans to mere taxpayers and servants of the State and treats inconvenient people who say that AGW is a Hoax as so much refuse.
The “cure” for globull warming is many, many thousands of times worse that even the worst scenario that they have dreamed up.
So much anti-Science from the Left makes it seem like we're living in a George Orwell play.
Hey Pontiff, 1984 was supposed to be a WARNING not a blueprint!
“The bigger the lie, the more it will be believed.”
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Joseph_Goebbels
what climate change?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.