LOL, all I'm asking is what it would take for you to forgive Josh. What would he have to do, at this point? You damn him freely and often. So, what's the flip side?
And, if you simply cannot see yourself ever forgiving him under any conditions, say so. It will help everyone understand why you condemn him so much. No one will hate you, most will understand that's just how you feel, even if they disagree with you. But fair's fair. If you're going to constantly yell "crucify him," at least admit you will accept nothing less for his crime.
Josh will have to wear this all of his life.
That is not my fault.
Had he and his family not wanted to be reality TV stars, we would have never heard of him.