Replies

Does this report present any evidence to support these claims?

The inflation WAS intentional. They've got very good evidence for that which they got from the locker room attendants. The question is whether Brady knew. Brady, for his part, refused to turn over any of his messages to the NFL. The fact that the "deflators" received gifts from Brady and mention discussions with Brady in their text messages is enough for me.

The NFL is not a court of law, so "beyond a reasonable doubt" doesn't necessarily have to apply here. I haven't read the entire report and have only read summaries, but at first glance it appears the "preponderance" of evidence suggests that Brady knew what was going on.

Here is a decent summary from Profootballtalk.

The first exchange was after an Oct. 17, 2014 game against the Jets when Brady complained about the pressure of the balls.

Jastremski wrote “Tom sucks. im going make that next ball a f—in balloon.”

McNally replied: “Talked to him last night. He actually brought you up and said you must have a lot of stress trying to get them done…”

McNally, apparently not a fan of Brady’s (or at least his level of attention of air pressure) made several references to pumping the balls up to “watermleon” or “rugby” size, since Brady preferred softer ones for better control.

Prior to the next game, McNally wrote: “The only thing deflating sun..is his passing rating.”

There was then a discussion of McNally receiving free shoes and gear, and prior to the Jan. 10 game against the Ravens, the two of them were in the equipment room with Brady when McNally “received two footballs autographed by Brady and also had Brady autograph a game-worn Patriots jersey that McNally previously had obtained.”

McNally later referred to himself as “the deflator,” and chided Jastremski by saying “im not going to espn……..yet.”

Those exchanges make it hard to imagine Brady had no knowledge of what’s going on, which he’ll need to answer for later.

Beginning in 2007, after teams were allowed to prepare their own game balls, NE Patriots fumbles went way down and stayed down from a long baseline. Also since that time, their bad-weather performance has been the best in the league.

Read the report. Text messages to the gofers about their “needles”? Come on.

They cheated, and have been cheating for a long time. I have no idea of the importance of this, I played right guard in 7th grade and almost got killed.

But the report makes it pretty clear what happened, and why.