He was a completely self-righteous little dictator. Most sailors have a love/hate relationship with the Old Man. Not this guy. He was universally hated, from the wardroom on down.
I cannot remember a time when he could have done a good thing for his crew and seized the opportunity. He was a dick.
Now, the guy who relieved him was universally loved. Not that he had to do much to earn it. He just had to not be the other guy. LOL In all seriousness, he was a good guy.