That’s a tough one. Should homeschool kids have ZERO oversight? Not every parent is capable of doing an adequate job of educating their children, regardless of their good intentions.
But the other side is that the leftists who administer such oversight programs will be more concerned with the kids missing out on the early propagandizing that creates good little Marxists!
Statistics show that homeschool kids as a group do better than public school students. Not perfect, but of the two systems... the one that needs more “work” is the public school system. Until the government can get that worked out to at least be even with homeschooling.... their advice and “help” is not the solution.