What if the sin is so intrinsic to the sinner’s identity that the sin cannot be differentiated from the sinner?
Because it is a sinful lifestyle choice in other words.
A long time ago I asked that same question of a priest, an old guy. He said that it shows a malformed conscience.
Perhaps that's one for God to finally decide.
Also, given the society we live in I find it hard to believe that the intrinsic sin can't be "figured out," undone or mitigated in some way. That ability is "intrinsic" to humans: we can change, if we really want to. We aren't "old dogs" who are unable to learn new behaviors.
Just an opinion.
In my personal work, i have much dealings with the homosexual community for many many years. Most good upstanding and fine folks. Misguided but good people who work very hard. However, I have also had to deal with homosexuals that am pretty sure are demonic possessed. Am thinking thats what we have happening. This is nothing less than demonic behaviour..