So before the insurance pays for anything other than the mandated tests, Ms. Willmus will have to pay out $5,000 in addition to whatever premiums she pays before the claim occurs.
There is no out of network coverage, except for emergency room care or transport, so in the event she needs to see a specialist outside of her network she's uninsured. Instead of the old limits on coverage, she'll have none at all when she needs it most.
Every teacher's union health insurance plan I have ever seen has much lower deductibles, and much better coverage than what Ms. Willmus has signed up for.