[SoConPubbie]

What value is there in having one citizen parent rather than none? What would be the point?

If the reason for the NBC requirement is to eliminate a chief cause of questionable loyalty, how is that accomplished if one parent is a citizen of a foreign country?

What you think it should be or what you think is logically the definition does not equate to existing settled US Law, Supreme Court rulings, or relevant parts of the US Constitution.

[William Tell]

SoConPubbie said: "What you think it should be ..."

What do you think it should be? I'm of the opinion that the Constitution should have the meaning that our Founders intended. If settled law disagrees with that, then settled law is wrong and should be changed.