[oldenuff2no]

I got to the word always and quit. Whenever you get to those words in a “the moon is falling” article you know they are just bold faced lying.
Always and never are almost never true but are the words used by zealots who do not want to have a logical truthful, factual, discussion on a given subject. What they are trying to feed the readers is that, “this is over, this is decided, because I SAID SO.”

BS

The top producers from our schools right now are not from home schools but are Asians who attend our public schools.

[wintertime]

but are Asians who attend our public schools.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

These kids are being afterschooled.

Where is the evidence that these ambitious Asians are getting their education in their government indoctrination camp? Show me the studies.

Where are the studies that separate out what is learned in their government indoctrination camp for that acquire OUTSIDE THE SCHOOL in home from the parents, cousins, aunts, uncles, friends and STUDY CLUBS?

I will make an “always” and “never” statement:

Without these studies it is impossible to know if government schools teach anything at all.

So?....Prove it. Prove that the schools are the reason for the success of Asians. Where are the studies? Or...Are you merely making assumptions due your own early childhood indoctrination?

[demshateGod]

The term “top producers” can’t just be taken at face value. You might have to consider our culture as a whole and whether public education has played a role in its decline. That it is in decline is self-evident to most. That education has played a role should be self-evident. To the extent that is isn’t self-evident, speaks to the claim that public education is a government entitlement. Few people are willing to give up entitlements after generations of being on them.

[Trailerpark Badass]

The top producers from our schools right now are not from home schools but are Asians who attend our public schools.

And you don't attribute any of that to the "public school" part, do you?

because that would be stupid.

[BfloGuy]

The top producers from our schools right now are not from home schools but are Asians who attend our public schools.

The Asian families are able to overcome the destructive effects of modern American education but won't be able to hold on for long. It's too corrosive and designed specifically to minimize the role of the family. I agree that the article is a polemic -- but it isn't wrong.