It is literally that simple.
Oh you rational thinkers.
Have I not repeatedly told you, never, ever, ever try to use logic and reason with a liberal.
There are four insane liberals on SCOTUS and one is a trans-liberal-moderate-conservative.
You are correct, it should be 9-0, in fact it never should have gone this far, but logic and reason will not apply to liberals.
Sadly, I heard absolutely nothing out of Sonya Sotomayor which would indicate that she is a rational thinking adult.