[caww]

Because from the immigration definition of amnesty it means citizenship is also given...that is not what Newt’s plan entails.

They have to have a job...they will be fined.. they have to learn English...and they will not have citizenship if they accept being “legal”...otherwise they have to go back to their country and apply for citizenship thru normal proceedures. They will not be able to haul their extended families here.

[Rooivalk]

Because from the immigration definition of amnesty it means citizenship is also given...that is not what Newt’s plan entails. They have to have a job...they will be fined.. they have to learn English...and they will not have citizenship if they accept being “legal”...otherwise they have to go back to their country and apply for citizenship thru normal proceedures. They will not be able to haul their extended families here.

Why do they need anything from the United States. As you read this you clearly understand that these illegals are just that: ILLEGALS

This means that they are citizens of another country who are dwelling here in America...ILLEGALLY So it is not clear from you or Gingrich why we owe them a job or anything. They broke the law by coming here against OUR rules so the humane thing is to send them back to their country of origin as humanely as possible.

Once in their country of origin they have the right under our law to apply LEGALLY for entry into America.

I cannot see why folks like you cannot see the logic in that solution. Am I wrong?