Alex Colbin has all the rights of every resident of California. Including marriage.
Any eligible man can marry any eligible woman. Any eligible woman can marry any eligible man. Nobody is discriminated against in the existing marriage laws. Marriage has a definition which includes all who want to participate in it.
Alex can also enter into a domestic partnership in California, which has virtually all the legal rights and responsibilities of marriage. Tens of millions of dollars were spent by the gay activists over the legal definition of one word : marriage.
Somebody said why does anybody care about gay marriage, why are we talking about it, implying that we should just accept it. Obviously the gay activists care very much about how we define marriage in our society, otherwise they would be happy with the legal partnership rights they have gained in some states, and leave it at that.
the california court, drank the kookaid, and said sexual BEHAVIOR was immutable as skin color or genetic oragin.
Immutability equals rights in the eyes of the california courts.
not being able to have your BEHAVIOR recognized means your are discriminated against.