It’s simple.
The church just says no to the spoiled brat and offers her to leave and join another school.
No feel good “we care about your rights” like the rights of the unborn? Like the rights of schools to set the terms of what goes on in their halls? Or how about just standing up for our faith?
Just say no and be done with it.
Private schools are not public schools.
Freedom of expression doesnt apply to private businesses and schools. Try that at the private company you work at, and see how long you last.
The school, being a division of RCINC, in this case does not want to alienate wealthy alumni/donors who hold “enlightend views. RCINC doctrine and actions is very flexible when considering cash flow and donations.