[Arthur McGowan]

You have completely missed my point.

Catholics are NOT at liberty to say: “The Pope canonized JPII, but I think JPII is in Hell.”

Catholics are at liberty to say: “The Pope canonized JPII, but I think it was a bad idea because JPII is not an example of a great Pope.”

[piusv]

I HAVE NOT MISSED YOUR POINT.

Provide Church teaching that says a Catholic can say this about canonizations:

“The Pope canonized JPII, but I think it was a bad idea because JPII is not an example of a great Pope.”