No, the shouldn't when they have wholeheartedly and willfully given themselves over to Satan's agenda as the activists have.
This is the crux of the matter, right? We declare them "lost" and we go on congratulating ourselves as to how holy and pure we are in comparison. That's your solution? Sorry, I disagree.
~Theo
Just reading a bit of St. Catherine of Siena -- I can take just a bit at a time, because, good heavens, that woman is about 198 proof --- but she wrote that Jesus told her that "the greater the misery of a soul, the greater its right to My mercy."
I think of that.