[Gamecock]

There is no way to know.

Calvinists never claimed to be able to make that determination.

[kosciusko51]

Look at the parable of the wheat and the tares. Until the harvest, it is nearly impossible to tell the two apart.

[Boogieman]

Yes, exactly. Everything he points out is true, but it doesn’t really invalidate Calvinism, since Calvinism doesn’t claim to tell us who is and who isn’t saved.