Hmmm...I was always taught that if you have a better idea, a better way of doing things...whatever, people would adopt your solution because it makes sense. When you have a piece of crap to offer and, rightly, no one wants it (like Obamacare), you pass a law and force it down people's throats. Kinda sounds like Islam isn't the peoples' choice there.
Certainly sounds like the type of legislation that Mayor Bloomberg would support.