[boatbums]

Everyone who formally or materially supports a grave evil has been excommunicated, this includes those Catholics who voted for Obama and other pro-abortion candidates.

But nobody tells them they are...they are just supposed to "know" it? Tell me again what earthly good that does.

[Natural Law]

"Tell me again what earthly good that does."<\i>

It's not about earthly good.

Now tell me how you reconcile the opposing notions that Catholics are told what to think under penalty of damnation while complaining about a lack of punitive procedures and doctrinal discipline.