Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Appeals Court Refuses Reinstatement of French Fry Fall Suit
The Janesville Gazette ^ | October 8, 2003 | Robert Imrie / Associated Press

Posted on 10/08/2003 11:14:25 AM PDT by Chummy

Court refuses to reinstate lawsuit over slip on french fry

(Published Wednesday, October 8, 2003 09:17:49 AM CDT)

By Robert Imrie/Associated Press

WAUSAU, Wis. -- A divided state appeals court refused Tuesday to revive a woman's lawsuit that alleged a Green Bay arena was unsafe because she slipped on a ketchup-soaked french fry on a stairway and broke her ankle.

The 3rd District Court of Appeals said allowing the lawsuit to proceed as the woman contended would have impractical ramifications for stadiums, theaters, restaurants and shopping malls.

"Imagine, for example, the consequences for Lambeau Field when more than 70,000 people are trying to exit at the end of a football game," Judge Gregory Peterson wrote. "Are they all required to sit in their seats until custodians have inspected all the stairways, hallways, aisles and rows? How many custodians must the stadium employ?"

According to court records, Nancy Megal of Hortonville attended the "Pocahontas on Ice" show Feb. 6, 1998, at the Brown County Veterans Memorial Arena. The 4,220 spectators were free to take food or drink anywhere in the arena.

Megal slipped on the french fry as she and crowd left the arena. Her broken ankle required surgery and left her with permanent pain and disability, court records said.

Megal sued the arena and its insurance company, alleging a violation of Wisconsin's safe-place law, which requires public places to be kept "as safe as the nature of the premises reasonably permits."

Megal contended the arena was liable for her injuries either through its failure to clean the stairs where she fell or its method of operation in having too few custodians on duty.

She relied on two earlier cases in which similar lawsuits were allowed to proceed involving a slip on a prune in a grocery store and a slip on shaving foam on the floor at a self-serve men's cosmetics counter.

Courts ruled those lawsuits were proper because the store owners had "actual notice" of potential hazards.

Brown County Circuit Judge William Atkinson dismissed Megal's lawsuit, ruling she could not prove the arena had knowledge of the dangerous condition, the french fry on the step. The appeals court upheld the ruling in a 2-1 decision.

Peterson wrote there's no way workers could have patrolled the arena to be on guard for something like a spilled french fry, and Megal was unable to show what could have been done to prevent her injury.

"The safe-place law was never intended to make owners and operators insurers of the public's safety," he said. "The exception ... is very narrow."

In a 13-page dissent, Judge R. Thomas Cane said the majority opinion is improperly driven by public policy considerations, and a jury should resolve the dispute.

Megal declined comment Tuesday about the appeals court ruling, saying she first wanted to discuss it with her attorney. Her attorney, John Peterson, did not immediately return a telephone message from The Associated Press for comment.

TOPICS: Culture/Society; Miscellaneous; News/Current Events; US: Wisconsin
KEYWORDS: appeals; appealscourt; fall; freedomfries; frenchfries; greenbay; lawsuit; litigation; slip; wausau; wisconsin

1 posted on 10/08/2003 11:14:26 AM PDT by Chummy
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: Chummy
Note to Nancy Megal: Watch where you are going!!!

2 posted on 10/08/2003 11:18:32 AM PDT by Jaded (nothing but trickery abounds nowadays)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: All
The Free Republic Lifeform

"... This is a wonderful description of what Free Republic really is. It is a living and evolving Life Form to battle the left wingers and those who would destroy this country!

The Free Republic Life Form enables us to discover the truth about what is happening. We can avoid the spin of the major mediots as they work 24/7 to weaken this country. We come to the Free Republic Life Form to find the truth! ...

Free Republic needs a constant infusion of cash to keep the Free Republic Life Form alive, viable and to grow. If we believe in Free Republic, we must donate each month or quarterly to keep this incredible life form alive...

Good stewardship is what this world needs, not good intentions. Good conservative stewards will insure that the Free Republic Life Form continues to grow, be viable and thrives!"

Thank You for your support!

Click The Logo to Donate
Click The Logo To Donate

Or mail checks to

FreeRepublic , LLC
PO BOX 9771
FRESNO, CA 93794

or you can use

PayPal at

3 posted on 10/08/2003 11:18:55 AM PDT by Support Free Republic (Your support keeps Free Republic going strong!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Chummy
Wet rocks are slippery too, especially when they're on a slope. Whom do we sue? God?
4 posted on 10/08/2003 11:18:58 AM PDT by cake_crumb (UN Resolutions = Very Expensive, Very SCRATCHY Toilet Paper)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: cake_crumb
Why can't accidents happen any more? It's always negligence on someone's part now.

How suits like this actually make it to court sickens me.

5 posted on 10/08/2003 11:39:42 AM PDT by crv16
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: Chummy
Maybe this case would have succeeded if they used the term "Freedom Fry" when the case was filed.
6 posted on 10/08/2003 11:49:53 AM PDT by Mark (Treason doth never prosper, for if it prosper, NONE DARE CALL IT TREASON.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: cake_crumb
If I'm not mistaken, you would sue the State the slippery
rock is in (just being sarcastic).
7 posted on 10/08/2003 11:56:34 AM PDT by KateUTWS (Firmly ensconced in Conservative country)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: Chummy
Is there a pic at all? Why do I get the feeling that this woman is "plus sized?"
8 posted on 10/08/2003 12:08:10 PM PDT by doodad
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: crv16
"Why can't accidents happen any more? It's always negligence on someone's part now"

THAT is the problem. Tort reform is the beginning of the answer. Trial lawyers are to blame for every single freedom taken away from us in this country. From losing our freedom to swim in the local swimming hole because some idiot couldn't read a sign to restrictions on guns to the prices of our medications. Heck, they tried to take my sinus pills away because a few people CLAIM they don't know that anything ending in an "ine" is SPEED.

I have noticed that since the left brought all of it's power to bear to attack the president over Iraq, he has been silent on his two pet peeves : environazi regulations and trial lawyers in general. There was a time recently when EVERY speech by the president had a mention of trial lawyers. I'm not hearing that anymore. His vendetta against trial lawyers and the damage they cause to all of us is one of the things I admire most about him.

I miss it, and don't think it's a coincidence that he has been forced to stop while fending off concerted attacks from the left.

We won't get our country back until we get the ability to reign in the trial lawyers. The good news is the SCOTUS overturning some ruinous awards from tobacco lawsuits and SUV lawsuits, so maybe we have a beginning going on quietly after all.

9 posted on 10/08/2003 12:43:25 PM PDT by cake_crumb (UN Resolutions = Very Expensive, Very SCRATCHY Toilet Paper)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: Chummy
How many custodians must the stadium employ?"

The litigious wench should employ her eyes and the handrail.

10 posted on 10/08/2003 12:49:35 PM PDT by SpinyNorman
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: doodad
Well, her common sense sure can't qualify for that label!
11 posted on 10/08/2003 10:05:12 PM PDT by Chummy
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 8 | View Replies]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794 is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson