Posted on 10/03/2023 8:04:12 AM PDT by Vlad0
Did you read the article?
About Troop comparisons
Then there is ammo
This war has basically disarmed the UK army whose Defence Chief just stated they have no more weapons to give……and reduced stocks in the other NATO countries to a few days of fighting! Ginning up military production will take a year or more…even from the US
NATO has basically been fooked by Biden and Zelensky…yet the demands continue.
I’m more worried about how the US Troops will do against the Chinese within our border, and on the Canadian border just waiting orders.
I agree whole heartedly, sad to see what is taking place. Fortunately I have see better days never to return during the time I have left. Thanks for your reply!
Thanks for the summary. I agree with your decision to post this not because the analysis is surprising but because it’s good to keep an eye on how the attention paid to potential conflict with Russia continues and develops. Someone dismissed this as a student article, but it’s actually by a lieutenant colonel and a professor.
I’ve been posting about this for years and it is one of the benefits for the West coming out of this war, the seeing of this and the overall consumption of men, ships, air, weaponry, fuel, etc. if we have a major war with China for instance where all the stops are pulled out.
I have been calling it bench depth, where Divisions are being overrun and ammo and food not reaching the front, large units are being cut off and on their own, chaos and uncertainty everywhere on the front, can our military supply it, and can our soldiers hold up mentally and emotionally.
“Did you read the article?”
The casualty rates in the article (3,600 per day) were not from some model of a war with Russia - they were generic planning factors for a high intensity conflict, out of Field Manual (FM) 4-0, Sustainment Operations (footnote 12 in the article).
The reality is that Russian forces arrayed against NATO have been cut by 4/5ths, to feed into the Ukrainian meatgrinder. NATO has gone on a military spending spree, and the addition of Finland and Sweden are far from trivial. Finland fields the largest Artillery force in Europe, and Sweden will bring effective control over the Baltic Sea.
Russia has burned through the better half of its gear, while for the first year The West was basically providing old Warsaw Pact leftovers to Ukraine. The Western platforms that been provided are mostly old Vietnam or Gulf War era stuff, that was no longer on operational status.
NATOs Operational forces have grown since the start of the war in Ukraine, and are more forward deployed. All our modern stuff is fully on hand, except for 155mm Artillery ammo and shoulder fired ATGMs and SHORAD (which have largely already done their work attritting Russian platforms ahead of time.
The initial shock and awe opening salvos of a full conflict with NATO would blast Russian conventional forces into pieces, before they could inflict mass casualties on the ground - So fast it would make their heads spin.
Somehow I do not think you attended the War College.
Or any military planning training.
Please correct me if wrong.
Sorry I couldnt get past the first para of your…thinking
The same folks who predicted 40,000 casualties in Desert Storm.
Most of Maine, New Hampshire and even Vermont are very conservative outside of the urban cesspools.
I believe you will find that during the Napoleonic Wars, the British had conscription into the active Militia -- meaning it was called into full time service, but not liable for service on the continent. Each county, and parish, was given a quota of conscripts, to be selected by lottery, and there was a "buy out" provision, meaning for X in pounds "£x" the recruit could buy his way out of service. But it also meant that local officials who were opposed to the war, or perhaps supported the war, but thought it was being conducted by idiots, could pay the £x for all the conscripts they were obligated to produce, and thus spare their young men from conscription.
By the way, my gut feeling is that where I stay in Puerto Rico they will get zero support.
“I do not think”
You said it.
I saw post 86 as a list of facts except for the last sentence of educated opinion, which is pretty darn close to being fact.
You skipped over the entire post of facts to make an irrelevant wisecrack.
Your reality is not where facts dwell.
The first para:
“The reality is that Russian forces arrayed against NATO have been cut by 4/5ths, to feed into the Ukrainian meatgrinder. NATO has gone on a military spending spree, and the addition of Finland and Sweden are far from trivial. Finland fields the largest Artillery force in Europe, and Sweden will bring effective control over the Baltic Sea.”
No need to discuss further.
Some ridiculous ignorance inspires no response. The “wise crack” was, indeed, gratuitous.
They predicted more than that.
It was a very sobering time.
The Rada just raised the conscription age for men to 65.
Senior officers- to 70.
Nothing says winning like drafting an army of senior citizens.
They’re not going to outrun the artillery fire, are they.
You know how many Ball bearing manufacturers are left in this country? Know where we get bearings now? Know how many ships, planes .tanks,vehicles use bearings, All of them, we are screwed !
Still nothing from you in response to those facts except some wise-cracking.
I was pretty sober sitting outside All Khafji with the King Abdul Aziz Motorized Rifle Bde.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.