“Something doesn’t match up in this story.”
Exactly!
She voted and she had a Social Security Card, and conveniently, no U.S. Passport.
That’s Fraud!
You need to quit using words you don't understand. "Fraud" is deception "by definition!"
How do you "deceive" from ignorance of ones true status?
Frankly, as another poster said, I'm more inclined to believe the Social Security Administration screwed up than this ladies parents made up their story from whole cloth.